Saturday, October 12, 2019

The Cause of the Schism of 1054 According to The Western View Part One


When we think of splits from church history there are probably two that most likely come to our minds: The Protestant Reformation, and The Great Schism of 1054. Church splits have significant consequences, and some of them, at least so far, have never been healed. This post will focus briefly on The Great Schism of 1054, from the Western perceptive.
 I was looking at several Crusade accounts recently, and found it interesting that they talked about their distaste for the Greek Christians. Of those differences from the Greek Christians they named, The Filioque, and some differences over the priesthood, as well as their rite of Mass were all that was essentially mentioned. Nothing was mentioned of Papal Supremacy. Yes, that is right! I believe that that is because the papacy was not nearly as powerful at that time in the sense of infallibility or great supremacy, as we think of it today.
 While the issue of papal supremacy deserves attention for a future post, for now I'd like to reflect on what Western Christians said about the Greeks from their own words. This can give us perspective to what Western Christian believe, as well as insight to why the Great Western Schism happened.
 What was it that sparked the Great Western schism? I won't get into that long history, though I may do some of that in the future! For now, let the accounts speak for themselves.
 ''We think it worthwhile to make a brief note of the beliefs of the Greeks that differ from the faith of the universal church, namely that of the Holy Roman Church. They are in error about their belief about the Holy Trinity, since they teach that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father alone, and not from the Son, and is less important than the Father and Son. In the Eucharist, they use Azyme, and in that sacrifice of solemnity of the Mass they do not offer that reverence, care and compunction of the heart with which we, although sinners and unworthy, celebrate and use. They make no distinction between their priests and other clerics, apart from the bishops, and peasants, and thus show no respect for the divine cult. They make no change to the chant or to the prayers from the collect for the feast days during the year or the saints' days, apart from the Biblical readings and the Gospels. They anathematise all those who do not agree with their beliefs: they describe all Christians, whether spiritual or secular people in the popular idiom, as secular, and they pour out arrogant prayers for their conversion. They describe themselves alone as spiritual and orthodox.  They separated themselves a long time ago from the jurisdiction of the Holy Roman Church, and they make themselves subject in divine matters only to their own patriarch, whom they describe as 'universal, ' giving this Greek patriarch of Constantinople precedence over the other two patriarchs of Jerusalem and Antioch by name alone. Their priests and clergy are neither vowed to nor observe continence. ''
 -The Crusade of Frederick Barbarossa: The History of The Expedition of the Emperor Frederick and Related Text translated by G. A. Loud.

As you can see, this Crusade account actually criticized the Greeks for the concept of a universal bishop. While many today wrongly assume that it was just the Popes of Rome that taught this, in reality, Greek Patriarchs taught it. It was to the concept of universal bishop by a Greek Patriarch that Pope Gregory the Great wrote was ''Antichrist.'' Though properly understood, Gregory actually saw himself as the head of the church. For more information on this, check out the following link:
 https://christianhistoryinstitute.org/incontext/article/gregory-the-great.



Saturday, October 5, 2019

Those ways the Classical Greeks and Medieval Man were alike




If I were but a pagan, I would now implore the Muses to come help me write, but I have a greater inspiration to write, and that is from The Blessed Trinity.




It maybe a surprise to modern readers to learn that the pagan Greeks of Ancient history and the Western Europeans of the Middle Ages shared much in common. Both valued and loved the earth, both enjoyed plays and drama, and both were very artistic. Medieval man indeed drew much from the classical Romans and Greeks.
 The influence of the classics upon Western man is perhaps never more tangible and obvious than in Medieval Literature. For instance,  The Divine Comedy by Dante Alighieri was influenced by Virgil's The Aeneid.
 Beyond literature however, Medieval man learned much from the Greeks, including philosophies from Plato and Aristotle that were adopted in Scholasticism, which defended the dogmatic teachings of The Latin Church. As examples of this, Augustine was influenced by Plato, and Aquinas by Aristotle. Even in their historical understanding, those writers and poets of the Middle Ages, especially the English, believed they were descendants of the Trojans. This theory, was promulgated in Geoffrey of Monmouth's The History of the Kings of Britain.
 Medieval man took much from the scientific understanding of the Greeks including Geocentrism, the belief that the earth is at the center of the universe.
 Medieval times saw a loss of of knowledge concerning the Greek language in the West, though it was preserved in the east. Western Europeans more commonly spoke Latin in the early Middle Ages, and it would not be until shortly before The Renaissance that knowledge of Greek would again be common in the west. Scholars of the era, valued the writings of Virgil and Cicero.
During the Renaissance, the Christian Humanists wanted a return to the knowledge of Greek.
Desiderus Erasmus greatly contributed to this endeavor, with his Textus Receptus forming the basis for the later King James Version of the Bible. The ideals of Christian Humanism, are expressed in The Imitation of Christ by Thomas A Kempis.
Renaissance art took much of it's style from the arts of the classical age. This was a bit controversial, as some Christians felt it was inappropriate with it's emphasis on naked individuals, such as the Nudity of David by Michelangelo.


                                              Above, Minerva, The Roman goddess of Wisdom. 


 
                                           


The similarities between the Classical Greeks and Romans compared with the Medieval Western Europeans, do not override the differences of course. The Greeks worshiped drama, Medieval Christians used it to convey Biblical stories and Morality Plays, especially as concerning the role of man in eternity. The Greeks also did not derive their worldview from the Bible, whereas Medieval man did. The Greeks worshiped many gods, whereas Medieval man worshiped only one God, The Blessed Holy Trinity. The purpose of this article has been merely to show that despite great differences, Medieval man took much from his ancient predecessors of the Classical Mediterranean world. Much more detail could be written on this, and I'd like to take that endeavor for sometime in the future. For now however, I wish to stick to merely an introduction to this very subject.



          The Greek theater introduced the world to many things, including to the the genre of Tragedy.





The Nudity of David from The Sistine Chapel



The artwork of the Renaissance world reflected humanity much more personally than Medieval art had done. Truly the golden age of art, was reborn with the Renaissance, as artwork moved further and further away from the The Icons and earlier handwork, that had placed much emphases on the divine. Still, some of the most famous Biblical and Christian artwork is from the Renaissance, though that is a worthy subject all it's own for another day. 











The Roman poet, Virgil, would greatly influence Saint Augustine, and later lead Dante through Hell, Purgatory, and Heaven in Dante's Divine Comedy. His poem, The Aeneid, includes the story of the Trojan horse which was seldom actually mentioned in Homer's stories. The Aeneid has been called the most influential poem ever. His story promotes humanness and piety, as well as mercy towards those that suffer. 


                                        They can conquer, who believe they can. -Virgil




 Further Sources: Studies in Medieval and Renaissance Literature by C. S. Lewis, The Discarded Image: An Introduction to Medieval and Renaissance Literature by C. S. Lewis, The Golden Book of the Renaissance by Irwin Shapiro, Western Civilization I by Robert Ziomkowski, The Politically Incorrect Guide to Western Civilization by Anthony Esolen.

A Review of the Trojan War by Olivia Coolidge

 

I recently finished The Broadview Anthology of British Literature Volume A. This book gives a good start for anyone interested in the history of the subject. Now that I have finished it, I have gotten back to the reading of literature again.


As I am making my way through The Iliad and The Odyssey, I attempt to post more about the literature of the Classical world in the following weeks. While this literature is not ''English Literature'', it no doubt influenced it, and thus has reason to be conversed about here. Many English writers including Geoffrey Chaucer, William Shakespeare, and John Milton took from Greek mythology, and that's just naming a few. In more recent times, C. S. Lewis, J. R. R. Tolkien, and J. K. Rowling have all been heavily influenced by Greek mythology. Lewis, Tolkien, and Rowling were Readers in Classical Studies during college after all.
  I first became interested in the Greek Myths as early as I can remember, but it was a friend librarian that encouraged me to read Homer and Virgil when I was around the age of twelve/thirteen. As he was into the American Civil War as I was, he recommended that I read the Greeks as their stories and warfare were heavily influential on the Americans during The War Between the States. I first studied the history of the Greeks for the next few years, before reading The Trojan War by Olivia Coolidge. This book greatly influenced me, perhaps one of the most influential books on me that I have ever read. Immediately, I became fascinated by the Greek Culture, and incorporated much of it's history and literature into my stories.
I would recommend all readers not yet familiar with the classics, to buy The Trojan War by Olivia Coolidge. This book is an easy and enjoyable read, that can be a good start for anyone that wants to understand The Iliad or The Odyssey. It gives a brief history of the Trojan War, with special emphasis on key characters like Achilles or Hector. Coolidge's book incorporates Homer and Virgil's stories, along with Aeschelues in one volume, made especially for young adults.


Saturday, September 28, 2019

Not all Medieval Studies are the Same



For the record, I will be returning to my posts on The Canterbury Tales soon. Since Spring, I have had many distractions on things going on elsewhere, though I feel pretty sure that I will be able to get back to my emphasis on Medieval Literature again soon. I hope that especially by 2020, that I maybe able to give more time to the reading of poetry, prose, and drama again.
 Colleges can very significantly on the courses, requirements, etc, needed to gain a degree. As some of you are aware, the certificate of Medieval Studies is something I'd like to pursue at the master's level.
 It turns out, that at the University of TN for instance, Medieval Studies at The Master's Level is actually an addition to the History or English department, one gains the certificate not separately , but with their actual major. In some colleges, The Medieval Program gives the degree at the graduate level, though it is not that way at UT.  With that known, I'd like to eventually pursue an M.A. in English, with the certificate of Medieval Studies.
 It is an unfortunate fact that many Medieval Study programs in this country are currently liberal. I was warned this by a close friend some years ago.



 Next year, I will be enrolling online for my undergraduate in English. All prayers will be appreciated.

Saturday, September 21, 2019

A Review of The Enchiridion: On Faith, Hope, and Charity


About a year ago I finished a lesser well known work of Saint Augustine, that is greatly appreciated by many scholars. I have read this work twice, and believe it to my favorite of those Augustine works that I have yet finished.
 The Enchiridion covers many theological issues including: is it ever morally right to lie?, the manner of how Free Will was lost at the fall, why some are predestined to hell, that God willed all those that are saved to be saved, the existence of Purgatory, and other topics.
 It is no wonder that Augustine's theology had great influence on Martin Luther and John Calvin, thought it should be noted, that Calvin clearly taught things that Augustine had never taught. While I'm pretty sure all would agree that the freedom of the will to not sin was lost by man after the fall, until he is called and made righteous before God, Augustine and Calvin would principally differ on two main areas: Augustine taught that man can justified and lose it, and Augustine taught that God's predestination of the damned is based on their demerits.  Calvin on the other hand, believed justification could never be lost, and that God's predestination of the damned was for His own glory alone. While Luther and Augustine would share much in common, they too would have differences. Luther would not teach the concept of mortal or venial sin as Augustine had believed. I'd like to get more into justification, predestination, free will, etc, in the future, particularity by describing these men's beliefs from their actual words. While I have read some from Luther and Calvin, I have read much more from Augustine, and no wonder, since I pretty well agree with Saint Augustine on every issue that I know of.
 For now, I will just say that all these issues are covered in this book. One of my favorite theological subjects is the free will of man, which is highly controversial among Christians.






Check out The Enchiridion: On Faith, Hope, and Charity. It is one of my favorites! 






Saturday, September 14, 2019

Some Reasons I like Tolkien's Middle Earth


 I have read The Hobbit, The Fall of Arthur, and The Children of Hurrin by J. R. R. Tolkien. More recently, I have finished reading The Lord of the Rings with my sister, Whitney. As a big Tolkien fan, I have read about the lives of C. S. Lewis and J. R. R. Tolkien for a very a longtime. The Lord of the Rings is one of my favorite books { yes, it's one book, not three}.
 That said, I have seen all the American adaptions of The Hobbit and LOTR on screen that I am aware of. I like the cartoons from Warner Brother and Rankin Bass, as well as the live actions films by Peter Jackson.
 I love The Chronicles of Narnia, but I really think The Lord of the Rings is more beautifully written. Tolkien was truly a master of the English language. His stories are very poetic, written in a strong rhythm like you find in fine music, for each chapter does not miss a beat of being a worthwhile read. Aside from it's style, LOTR is also quite spiritual without being allegorical. Many Catholic elements are found in Lord of the Rings as one would expect of such a traditional Roman Catholic. Tolkien was skeptical of Vatican II, The Mass being in the vernacular., and those changes he saw in both the world and the church near the end of his life. 
 Tolkien like C. S. Lewis was also homeschooled, something of course that I relate too. Like Lewis, he had a close relationship to his mother, and was fascinated by stories from a young age. It is no wonder that he later when on to be an English professor again like Lewis.
 Without getting too much more into Tolkien's life, perhaps the topic of a future post, let me add that I love the Medievalism of Tolkien's works. Yes, I am a Tolkien fan, and always will be.






Saturday, September 7, 2019

Bibles of the English Reformation: The King James Bible

   ''For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life.'' -John 3: 16, KJV.



    Brought on by Anglican and Puritan translators, The King James Version of the Bible was the most commonly used book by Colonial Americans. Called also The Authorized Version, or AV, The King James Version of the Bible is possible the most important work written in the English language.

                                 

King James in the above picture. 


This is my last post on the Bibles of the English Reformation. Tonight, I will focus on the literary work found in the King James Version, alongside the history that saw it's production.
 The King James Version of the Bible is the most sold book in the history of the world, with estimations of at least one billion in sales. Many presidents have sworn on it, and it has naturally become a part of English Language and Literature. The King James Version of the Bible has no copyright, which also explains it's availability at so massive of sails in the public market. For centuries, The King James Version of the Bible was valued by Protestants, though generally seen more negatively by American Roman Catholics, whom objected to the demand of American schools for their own children to read The King James Version.  Still Bishop Challoner, took from The King James Version of the Bible to produce a revised edition of The Douay Rheims Bible. 
 From time to time, though perhaps less common now than ever, some people may here about The King James Only debate. I of course have no interest in getting into the theological debate here of whether or not The King James Version of the Bible is the alone inspired Word of God. As I commonly do, I like to post about historical facts rather than theological opinions, and to share thoughts on great literary works of the past.



1611 would mark the year of The King James Bible's publication. 


1. The History of the King James Version of the Bible


King James I of England had greatly opposed the The Geneva Bible, which he despised, despite it's great popularity among the reformed English. The king has been reported to have disliked the Geneva Bible, primarily for it's notes, which supported Republicanism. Many Puritans came to agree England needed a Bible that the English and Scottish would both use, and King James would make sure that no notes would be part of his Bible translation, as he wanted a Bible that all Christians could use. 
 In 1604, King James assembled a synod to discuss the work of making a new English Bible. He appointed nearly fifty scholars, that were separated in about a handful of groups, as he commended them to make a conservative translation. This new translation was compiled by many scholars from Oxford and Cambridge Universities, and it took great influence from the previous Bible scholars, William Tyndale, and Myles Coverdale. Taking it's influence greatly from The Latin Vulgate, The Textus Receptus, and The Masoretic Text, The AV brought some of the best manuscripts and scholars of it's day to produce a great literary work. 

2. The Literary achievement of the King James Bible

One of the most significant differences from The King James Version in comparison to other Protestant versions is it's more moderate understanding of subjects like monarchy and good works. The King James Bible retained the use of ''Charity'' rather than ''Love'' in 1 Corinthians 13. This is more significant than many modern readers may expect, for charity implies good works, and marks The King James Version as closer in the middle of Roman Catholic and Protestant translations, despite still being Protestant. In Romans 13, The KJV says those that go against the goverment shall be damned, in contrast to simply being ''punished'' as was taught by The Geneva Bible.  In those senses, The King James Version was the most conservative Protestant Bible. The AV was clearly pro-monarchy. 
Perhaps, most significant is the fact that even today, it is still the basis for essentially all other English Bibles. The AV has become an authority all it's own.  Even though many King James Bibles now include notes in them, and have removed the Apocrypha, this was not the intent of the original translators, that made a most moderate version of the Bible in English. It is understandably then, that The King James Bible, is quite universally accepted among many Christians. 




3. Sources: In the Begining by Alister Mcgrath, The Nortan Anthology of English Literature, English Literature by Benjamin W. Griffith. 



                                                                           4. Final Summary



With all that said, I appreciate the great work of the translators of England's masterpiece. I also look forward to moving on to writing and researching new subjects of literature. I hope you enjoyed this series on the Bibles of the English Reformation. Blessings, Josh.