Satire can help us see errors in other people's religion, politics, or social life. It can also though, demonstrate a good amount of humor about a given literary work. The Comedy of Robin Hood Men in Tights {which I watched with Clear Play to remove the crude humor}, I found most amusing.
The film gives many pokes to some other well know Robin Hood films: The Adventures of Robin Hood, and Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves. Cary Elwes played a Robin Hood much akin to Errol Flynn, but the film as a whole was mostly directed with satire toward Robin Hood Prince of Thieves. Between cheap sets and exaggerated sword play, I thought this film also had a good amount of development between the characters {which we rarely see any more.}Also, it had a remarkable cast of actors including Patrick Stewart as Richard I. This has been the sixth Robin Hood film I have seen.
If you like satire and Medieval humor, you may enjoy this film{ though, there is a lot of crudeness and content in it without a TV blocker}. Anyhow, I was genuinely surprised that the film did not mock the Middle Ages as an ignorant and barbarous time. So for me, that was also a big brownie point for it!
Saturday, November 16, 2019
Saturday, November 9, 2019
How White Supremacy Gives the Middle Ages a Bad Name
Frequently, people mock the Middle Ages as the ''Dark Ages.'' Conservative Christians are often condemned as Medieval for holding theological or socially conservative views. There is already much ignorance about the Middle Ages among modern people, and White Supremacist groups don't help enlighten may people's ignorance about the subject.
First of all, it should be noted that many White Supremacist are actually atheist, not Christian at all. Add further to that, many of them are not even conservative. Richard Spenser is a leading White Nationalist that supports the rights of abortion and universal healthcare. Spenser also believes people's rights are not from God but from communities. Although the mainstream media condemn these groups as ''Far Right'', that is not the entire story. Some of them even supported President Obama, and many of them are clearly left on a number of issues. For more information on this topic see Death of a Nation by Dinish D' Souza.
Moving on, my point is not to demonstrate that racist are all left or right, but simply to demonstrate that there are many racist on both sides of the spectrum. The KKK may tend to be more religion and right leaning than Neo-Nazis, yet a racial identity they all hold too. With that as a background, I will now discuss some of the dangers White Supremacy has posed for defending the Middle Ages.
White Supremacist have a long history in America, and some trace the early roots of White Supremacy to the Spanish Conquistadors that came to America centuries ago. While the roots of White Supremacy, would make an interesting post all it's own, for now I just to want to address the given topic.
White Supremacist quite often use Medieval Symbols on their flags, outfits, and groups. Of course, the anger of White Nationalist groups only enrages the current racial tensions in this country, and not only that, but gives the mainstream media another opportunity to criticize The Crusades and Medieval World all over again. And sadly, many modern people don't think for themselves, nor do their own research. Whatever is popular, whatever is socially acceptable, the culture goes for, and if culture went left or right tomorrow, so would the majority of people.
There is a significance difference between The Medieval Church's stand against heresy and paganism, and what the rising trend of White Supremacy promotes. Contrary to liberal lies, The Crusades were initiated out of an act of love, as I have written about elsewhere, White Supremacy is out of hatred for minorities. The Medieval World based it's worldview upon The Scriptures and Tradition, White Supremacist only use these when they are convenient for them. In fact, White Supremacist admire the power of a White controlled Western Medieval Europe and admire it, but all the while not imitating it's religious worldview. White Supremacy is not rigid Orthodoxy that attempts the world of heresy and paganism, but rather to make an all powerful White race akin to the worldview of Adolph Hitler. The Catholic Church has never promoted racism in all of it's history. In reality, racism, which has always existed, has been more promoted by Charles Darwin and Social Darwinism than it has ever been by the Middle Ages.
In short, I pray and hope that many will stopping blame Medieval Culture for the sins of the present growth of White Supremacy in the West.
Roman Catholics and The Crusades
Saint Bernard pictured above
In a post from last week, I discussed some of the major views Protestants had towards The Medieval Crusades. Today, I will touch briefly on how Roman Catholics understood this subject.
First of all, The Crusades were usually called upon by the Catholic Church, so it's no surprise that Roman Catholics historically supported the Crusades. In fact, Roman Catholics almost universally supported The Crusades even centuries after the Middle Ages.
There was some criticism towards events that occurred during The Crusades. Pope Innocent III did not approve of the Fourth Crusade's Sack of Constantinople is one such example. Saint Bernard of Clairvaux was proclaimed ''as the greatest preacher of the gospel,'' by Martin Luther. Saint Bernard preached against killings of Jews during the Second Crusade, and later Saint Francis of Assisi was against the immorality of Crusaders in Egypt. That said, Pope Innocent III, Saint Francis of Assisi, and Saint Bernard all supported The Crusades.
All Crusaders were Latin Christians { Medieval Christians did not use the term Roman Catholic}.
During the Reformation era, the Saracens tried to invade Southern Europe but were stopped at the Battle of Lepanto in 1571. This victory has often been attributed to the help of the Virgin Mary. Today, many Roman Catholics are unaware of the origins of ''Our Lady of the Rosary.'' In reality, this came from The Battle of Lepanto, which gave the Crusaders a great victory over the Saracens. Roman Catholics historically called it ''Our Lady of Victory'' though.
Though The Crusades are the subject of heat in the modern world and continue to face backlash by the hatred promoted by White Supremacist, The Crusades were actually supported largely by both Roman Catholics and Protestants.
Saint Bernard drinking milk from Mary's breast.
Further Sources: Encyclopedia of the Crusades by Alfred J. Andrea.
Saturday, November 2, 2019
A Catechism Defending The Crusades, and other Aspects of Medieval Western Culture Part One
This catechism has been written primarily for misunderstandings of The Middle Ages and The Crusades in particular, by Evangelical Christians, though it can certainly be used for all. It is written in a typical objection response format, so that I respond to those objections raised by the criticisms made of Medieval Times. I felt that form of writing was needed, to best explain this subject to readers.
Before I proceed to the catechism, it should be noted that entire volumes of books could be written on this subject. History is very complicated, and more complicated than hecklers on street corners or politicians often present it. The most glorious events of history are usually imperfect, due to man's sin. But mistakes or abuse don't illigintimize a Holy Cause, what matters was if something was a Holy Cause from the start or not, more than how it was abused or later exaggerated. For this very reason also, unfair generalizations of cultures, religions, or people groups should always be avoided. I have said it many times, those that criticize The Medieval Crusades will regret the day that the Islamic armies invade the West for the kill, capture, and slaughter of all Christians and Jews. Apologizing to Muslims for the Crusades, in an attempt to convert them to Christianity is an act of conformity to the Jihad the Muslims brought on against the Christians from the start this. Let me add further, we don't apologize for truth to ''convert'' people. Also, no matter how well the intent of these same Christians are, they are actually be foolish by apologizing for wars that were clearly acts of self defense against an aggressive Islamic invasion on the West.
This paper has included works from various historians and theologians.
Objection I: Pope Urban II said every Crusader was guaranteed a place in Heaven, and he got involved in a Conflict, in which church leaders have no right to be involved.
Response: To the first part, I will respond first. Actually no, Pope Urban II did not say this. What he said is actually more clear in the several accounts written of his speech by his contemporaries including Fulcher of Charteres. First of all, The pope promised a Plenary Indulgence to those that repented, which is quite different than him promising salvation also to the unrepentant. Second the pope didn't even promise salvation to the repentant, though he did promise them if they were repentant free of debt, both monetarily , and spiritually. What this meant, was that any Crusader did not have to pay debts of money he now owed, and second, no knight had to pay restitution for certain sins he had previously committed, so long as he repented. Whether or not one agrees with Indulgences is another discussion. For now, however, let me affirmed that the pope did not promise a free ticket to Heaven to anyone who went on Crusade, and if the pope had, he would have contracted both the Roman Catholic and Protestant understandings of justification, but Urban is not guilty of this on either account. Those that have accused the pope of this, should not only correct their error, but inform others of the actual truth.
To the second part of the above objection, much of this can go back to historical context, the pope was not only a spiritual leader, but a political one. Some criticize the Crusades because the pope called for it, and say that wars should be fought by kings rather than by popes. They that make these assumptions and hold to these views forget or ignore several important facts, Medieval Culture was much different than our own, the concept of Separation of church and state did not really come about until the Enlightenment. Also, in many cases, it was the church that granted kings the authority to preside over local kingdoms. But last and most important, Emperor Alexius asked the pope to help them against the Islamic Invasion on the East. That too, is quite different than Pope Urban II just suddenly asking for a Crusade with no employment made toward him of the wars already existing between Muslims and Christians. The pope had a responsibility to do, and that was not simply to preach the Gospel, but to protect Christendom from heresy, which would have arisen from the abominable sect of Mohammed in the West if the pope had not made this move. In reality then, The Crusades were protecting the flock from heresy, and church leaders always have the responsibility to protect their flock, just as Urban did here.
Further Sources: The First Crusade by Edward Peters.
Protestants and the Crusades
A picture of the Lollards
John Wycliffe was a late Medieval reformer, who saw himself as a student of Saint Augustine. He faced opposition from within the Roman Church and would be sent into exile for his commitment to his beliefs. Wycliffe's followers were known as the Lollards. Their name etymology is unclear, though some believe it was named after a Franciscan. Their theology was also quite broad, though poverty was a big part of their movement. Some of them were involved in the Peasants Revolt against King Richard II, for which Wycliffe was blamed, though he had never condoned this.
The Lollards later revolted against King Henry V of England and were subsequently defeated. By the reformation, they seemed to have still existed, however, and they have always been honored as forerunners of the English Reformation.
In 1394, 10 years after Wycliffe's death, The Lollard Conclusions were written. These documents criticize the Roman Church in several areas, including ''manslaughter'' in the tenth article. The document does not clearly refer to the Medieval Crusades, though it does criticize those who invade Christian lands and conquer them only for land, and for those who kill heathens to give themselves a better name. After a careful reading of this document, in contrast to my previous conclusions, however, I am not convinced that the Lollards were not criticizing the entire crusades movement. It seems more likely that they opposed those who in the crusades man-slaughtered all in their way. Regardless, Wycliffe's influence was beyond them and unto the great Chaucer.
Geoffrey Chaucer's The Canterbury Tales is one of the most important works of Medieval Literature, and certainly one of my favorites. Of the traveling pilgrims, we have the knight, from whom we are told The Knight's Tale. Chaucer speaks of this knight having fought in crusades, wars, and many battles, and is likewise praiseworthy of the knight's character. This is all relevant, as we are unclear where Chaucer was theological. He was a student of Wycliffe, and there are strong arguments that he was a Lollard himself. On the theological side of Chaucer, he purposely intended to teach doctrine from his book. Perhaps Chaucer's own desire to teach theology through his writings can be one indicator that he was a Lollard. Below, I have given a passage from a book to indicate this evidence.
Chaucer is theologically correct when he incorporates the same quote from Saint Paul that he used in ''The Nun's Priest Tale'': All that is written is written for our doctrine'' {X, I, 1083, VII, 3441-3442, Romans 15: 4}. The purpose of all literature is to teach ''doctrine,'' lessons conducive to salvation. Composing such works, Chaucer says was his ''intent.''
-A Companion to Chaucer's Canterbury Tales by Margaret Hallissy, p. 92.
Of course, one may argue for Chaucer having been a Catholic rather a Lollard. Indeed, I think there are strong arguments to be used on both sides of this debate which I do intend to address here. Assuming that Chaucer may have been Lollard however, is important considering that would make him among the pre-Protestant English writers.
Geoffrey Chaucer in the above pic.
The views of Protestants and the Crusades went on for much longer than Wycliffe and his followers. During the fifteenth century, many pre-Reformation movements helped to change ideas about the church and the world. For example, the Hussite Wars of 1419-1436 were fought between Crusaders and the followers of Jan Huss. The Radical Hussites would be defeated, and for the next century, there would not be major threats to the Roman hierarchy.
1517 marked an important year of great change for the Medieval/Renaissance West. A German Reformation followed Martin Luther in opposition to what they perceived as the works-based salvation that was taught by Rome. Luther's position hardened as his life went on and he eventually denounced the papacy as well as the Crusades in his 1529 treatise, On War Against the Turk. His attacks on the Crusades were mostly aimed at the papacy, and the fact that Luther believed just wars should have nothing to do with church clergy. He also believed that Church clergy should only preach the gospel and that it was the greatest of sins to force a person into one's religion. Luther's despise of the pope can above all be seen in the track. Indeed, wrote about the pope being worked than the Turk while wishing the latter's damnation. His views on the Medieval Crusades helped to shape the view of many in the Protestant Reformation after him.
In England, John Foxe's Voice of the Martyrs was quite notorious for its criticism if not demonizing of the Roman Catholic Church. The book also criticized the Crusades, though it did speak well of Richard the Lionheart.
Other Protestants, however, pressed on with the concept of ''Holy War''. The Puritans were not at all short of burning witches and killing heretics in the name of God. To them, there was a Holy War against Roman Catholics. Indeed, some have called the conquest of Oliver Cromwell of Ireland to be a Protestant Crusade.
The Protestant Reformation brought many changes to the Western World of the Middle Ages.: Religiously, theologically, politically, socially, and much more. For many centuries afterward, Medieval Times was seen as a dark ignorant time, full of inquisitions and bloodshed. While the Renaissance wanted to bring about a return to the Classical Golden Age of Rome, the Enlightenment wanted to distance itself entirely from Medieval Times, which it saw as superstitious. All of this changed with the Romantic era.
It was during The Romantic era (early nineteenth century), that many writers and poets began to appreciate the Medieval world again. Ballads were popular during this time as they had been in the so-called ''Dark Ages (a term which most historians now reject).'' It is no surprise that one finds such Medieval values of courtship in Jane Austin's novels, and in Sir Walter Scott's writings. Scott himself was a Calvinist Presbyterian elder, who took a generally positive view of the Crusades. He wrote important works of literature that have glorified Medieval life and culture including Ivanhoe and The Talisman.
During the Modern Age, The Crusades became a subject of hot debate. But that will be discussed in another post.
Geoffrey Chaucer in the above pic.
The views of Protestants and the Crusades went on for much longer than Wycliffe and his followers. During the fifteenth century, many pre-Reformation movements helped to change ideas about the church and the world. For example, the Hussite Wars of 1419-1436 were fought between Crusaders and the followers of Jan Huss. The Radical Hussites would be defeated, and for the next century, there would not be major threats to the Roman hierarchy.
1517 marked an important year of great change for the Medieval/Renaissance West. A German Reformation followed Martin Luther in opposition to what they perceived as the works-based salvation that was taught by Rome. Luther's position hardened as his life went on and he eventually denounced the papacy as well as the Crusades in his 1529 treatise, On War Against the Turk. His attacks on the Crusades were mostly aimed at the papacy, and the fact that Luther believed just wars should have nothing to do with church clergy. He also believed that Church clergy should only preach the gospel and that it was the greatest of sins to force a person into one's religion. Luther's despise of the pope can above all be seen in the track. Indeed, wrote about the pope being worked than the Turk while wishing the latter's damnation. His views on the Medieval Crusades helped to shape the view of many in the Protestant Reformation after him.
In England, John Foxe's Voice of the Martyrs was quite notorious for its criticism if not demonizing of the Roman Catholic Church. The book also criticized the Crusades, though it did speak well of Richard the Lionheart.
Other Protestants, however, pressed on with the concept of ''Holy War''. The Puritans were not at all short of burning witches and killing heretics in the name of God. To them, there was a Holy War against Roman Catholics. Indeed, some have called the conquest of Oliver Cromwell of Ireland to be a Protestant Crusade.
The Protestant Reformation brought many changes to the Western World of the Middle Ages.: Religiously, theologically, politically, socially, and much more. For many centuries afterward, Medieval Times was seen as a dark ignorant time, full of inquisitions and bloodshed. While the Renaissance wanted to bring about a return to the Classical Golden Age of Rome, the Enlightenment wanted to distance itself entirely from Medieval Times, which it saw as superstitious. All of this changed with the Romantic era.
It was during The Romantic era (early nineteenth century), that many writers and poets began to appreciate the Medieval world again. Ballads were popular during this time as they had been in the so-called ''Dark Ages (a term which most historians now reject).'' It is no surprise that one finds such Medieval values of courtship in Jane Austin's novels, and in Sir Walter Scott's writings. Scott himself was a Calvinist Presbyterian elder, who took a generally positive view of the Crusades. He wrote important works of literature that have glorified Medieval life and culture including Ivanhoe and The Talisman.
During the Modern Age, The Crusades became a subject of hot debate. But that will be discussed in another post.
For more on the English Reformation's view of the crusades see
https://themedievalist.blogspot.com/2020/04/the-crusades-in-english-reformational.html
Further Sources: Holy Warriors: A Modern History of the Crusades by Jonathan Phillips, The Hussite Wars 1419-36 by Stephen Turnball, Crusades edited by Thomas F. Madden, Documents of the Christian Church Fourth Edition by Henry Bettinson and Chris Maunder, England and the Crusades 1095-1588 by Christopher Tyerman, Ireland 1649-1652: Cromwell's Protestant Crusade by Michael McNally, Richard Coeur de Lion: Kingship, Chivalry and War in the Twelfth Century by John Gillingham, English Literature by Benjamin W. Griffith.
Further Sources: Holy Warriors: A Modern History of the Crusades by Jonathan Phillips, The Hussite Wars 1419-36 by Stephen Turnball, Crusades edited by Thomas F. Madden, Documents of the Christian Church Fourth Edition by Henry Bettinson and Chris Maunder, England and the Crusades 1095-1588 by Christopher Tyerman, Ireland 1649-1652: Cromwell's Protestant Crusade by Michael McNally, Richard Coeur de Lion: Kingship, Chivalry and War in the Twelfth Century by John Gillingham, English Literature by Benjamin W. Griffith.
Monday, October 28, 2019
A book review of Medieval Beasts by Ann Payne
Medieval Art helps us understand the Medieval mind as much as Medieval Literature does. While some see Medieval art as boring or not advanced, I feel it brings out things about humanity that the later more humanistic art of the Renaissance doesn't. This is the first book I have read on Medieval Art, and for any Medievalist, I think it is a must read.
The book is largely about the great allegory of animals in medieval art. Dragons and foxes are symbols of the devil, whereas the lamb and the unicorn are symbols of Christ.
The book is full of illustrations from The Bestiaries, which included Medieval Artwork of various mythical and non-mythical animals. No doubt, C. S. Lewis must have known of this work, and I can see how it would have inspired The Chronicles of Narnia.
Medieval Art can be quite illuminating. It shows much about the people of it's time, including their religious worldview, and the settings of their culture.
While this post was brief and basic, I expect to take on topics of Medieval Art more in the future.
The book is full of illustrations from The Bestiaries, which included Medieval Artwork of various mythical and non-mythical animals. No doubt, C. S. Lewis must have known of this work, and I can see how it would have inspired The Chronicles of Narnia.
Medieval Art can be quite illuminating. It shows much about the people of it's time, including their religious worldview, and the settings of their culture.
While this post was brief and basic, I expect to take on topics of Medieval Art more in the future.
Thursday, October 17, 2019
A Review of Purgatorio by Dante and The Great Divorce by C. S. Lewis
I recently finished Purgatorio by Dante Alighieri and found it a great sequal to The Inferno, though perhaps as usual, also inferior to it's predecessor. The most memorable part of the story besides it's creepy tone is the fact that the gluttons are chained back from the foods they desired in life. Dante is guided by Virgil through most of the book until last cantos when he is directed by Beatrice instead.
Related to this Renaissance classic is the more modern Great Divorce by C. S. Lewis. In this book those that have died go on a bus and visit eternity. The damned actually do not desire Heaven, and those in Hell have their own theology clubs. Purgatory is also a key place in Lewis's work.
Purgatory was taught by Saint Augustine of Hippo in The Enchiridion: On Faith, Hope, and Charity. While it was not as popular in the east, it was certainly in the west for at least a thousand years before the Protestant Reformation.
Lewis actually believed in Purgatory though not in the sense that the 16th century Roman Catholic Church did. He discusses the subject of Purgatory and praying for the dead in Letters to Malcolm Whereas, Purgatory had been originally about purification, it became more and more about suffering instead. Hence, one can see how the change of understanding on this issue was used as a tool of power by many of the corrupt Roman Catholic hierarchy of the Reformation era.
That said, some Protestants have thrown the baby out of the bathwater. As one that was raised Evangelical Protestant, then became Roman Catholic, and now being a High Church Protestant, I have personally experienced and read the weak arguments made against Purgatory from evangelicals that are usually themselves not based off Scripture. Some Protestants contend that Purgatory takes away from what Christ did at the cross, but in no way is this true. Even in this life, after we are born again, we still face the consequences of our own sinful actions. Purgatory does not take away from Christ did at the cross, it's existence proves our lack of worthiness.
1 Peter 3: 19-20, 1 John 5: 6, 1 Corinthians 3: 13, and 2 Maccabess 12: 46 are common Scriptures used for the support of Purgatory's existence, and the need to pray for those that have died.
The Roman Catholic Douay Catechism was written for Protestants, and from my point of view is one of the best defenses of the Roman Catholic Faith. It gives no short exception to it's Biblical defense of Purgatory.
Two wrongs don't make one right, and throwing out doctrines because the Roman Catholic Church sometimes abused those doctrines is no exception.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)













