Monday, May 17, 2021

A Review of The Canterbury Tales: The Monk's Tale

 



                                                                       The Prologue: 


After hearing The Tale of Meliboeus, the host says that he wishes that his wife had heard it as well since he claims her to be a woman of impatience. He then encourages the monk to tell a new tale. 

''My lord the Monk,'' quoth he, ''be merry of cheer, 

For ye shall tell a tale truely.''

The monk agreed to tell two or three tales. Unfortunately, as Chaucer was never able to finish The Canterbury Tales, only one was ever written. 

                                                                       

                                                                         The Tale: 



The monk spoke of how great some can fall from prosperity. He exhorted all not to trust in riches and reminds them that it can be taken from them: 

''I will bewail, in manner of tragedy, 

The harm of them that stood in high degree, 

And felle so, that there was no remedy, 

To bring them out of their adversity. 

For, certain, when that Fortune list to flee, 

There may trust in blind prosperity; 

Beware by these examples true and old. 

The monk went on to describe the fall of Lucifer from glory. He then went to describe how Adam lost the beauty of Paradise due to sin. He then went on in more detail to describe the fall of Sampson as well. Likewise, the monk then went on to tell the story of Hercules downfall. He then went on to describe the fall of Nebuchadnezzar. The monk does not end here, however. Indeed, he goes on to recount similar stories of mighty characters that fell from glory. 


                                                                            My Analysis: 


The Monk's tale is not really a tale. No, indeed, it is a long discourse over how pride and power can bring those in high estates far beneath us all. All in all, a good message! 


Sunday, May 16, 2021

A Review of The Canterbury Tales: The tale of Meliboeus

 



                                                                              The Prologue 



In the prologue, Chaucer and the host briefly bicker before Chaucer goes on to tell a new story. The host complains of Chaucer's rhyme, but this seems to hardly drive back the English poet. Indeed, Chaucer has the full intention of now telling a moral tale. Nevertheless, the story that Chaucer is about to tell would not be unique to his imagination. In fact, Chaucer translated the story from one written by the French. Despite drawing from an earlier story, Chaucer understands the the moral importance of the upcoming text: 

''Gladly,'' quoth I, ''by Godde's sweet pine, 

I will tell you a little thing in prose, 

That ought like you, as I suppose, 

Or else certes ye be too dangerous. 

It is a moral tale virtuous, 

All be it told sometimes in sundry wise

By sundry folk, as I shall you devise. 


The prologue certainly sets the stage for a poem of great religiosity. Concerning its message, Chaucer seems to have had in mind a more serious tale here. On the other hand, some have interpreted it as more comical for its long length over the original French text. It has been suggested by some scholars that this tale is a companion to Chaucer's unfinished, The Tale of of Sir Thopas. Nevertheless, modern scholars generally see The Tale of Meliboeus as Chaucer's most boring work. 






                                                                        The Tale*1



Meliboues was a powerful and wealthy young man. He had a wife known as Prudence, and a daughter, known as Sophia. 

One day several men came into Meliboeus's house and beat his wife and daughter. When he found out about this he did greatly weep. 

Meliboeus's wife, Prudence, recalled lines from Ovid about suffering. In return, her husband spoke of how Christ did weep. His wife then spoke of the importance of weeping. Additionally, Solomon is quoted, and the sufferings of Job are discussed. 

Meliboeus then assembled many folks to his aid. Desiring vengeance, he asks his companions for wisdom. The young people encourage him to take vengeance while the old encourage him to refrain from such anger. Prudence then encouraged him to not go to war. He acknowledged her wisdom after she gave a long discourse about women helping men for guidance. Eventually, she even persuades him to not be angry and hasty to war. After agreeing with her wisdom, he asks her what thinks of his advisors. She tells him that these folks are folly and for him to follow his own rules of peace. Realizing his faults of angriness and hastiness, the text gives one of my favorite lines in all The Canterbury Tales: 

Granting that he erred, Meliboeus says that he is all ready to change his counsel right as she will devise; for, as the proverb runs, to do sin is human, but to persevere long in sin is work of the Devil. 

The wife then rebukes those among the counselors that had urged her husband to hastiness. Instead, she encourages peace to undo war. Likewise, she turns her husband towards Christ. For a woman that has been beaten along with her daughter she has an amazing strong attribute of self-control. Indeed, her husband is much graced by her strong faith. 

Prudence also reminds her husband of the authority of the judge to carry out justice. She is against those that attempt to carry out vengeance without trusting in the legal system to carry out justice. A few times he pridefully resists her pleas for him to be humble and patient. Nevertheless, he continues to listen to her as he knows that she is right. 

Next, the wife then met the men that had injured her family. She warned them of war and told them of the great hurt they had done to her family. Perhaps surprisingly, the men were surprised that she was not more scolding of them. Alas, Meliboeus and his wife were forgiving to those that sought their forgiveness. Indeed, Meliboeus encouraged them to obtain an indulgence*2. Last, all end with peace towards one another. 

Later, Meliboeus had the intention of punishing the men but his wife again turned him away from this. The story ends with him speaking about Christ will forgive us of our sins if we repent. 





                                                                           My Analysis: 


The theme of this story is that we should trust in God and not seek vengeance. As hard as it may be, we should never seek to punish those that have done us wrong. We have no room for hatred as Christ loves us even though we are far from perfection. 

The Tale of Meliboeus also exhorts husbands to listen to their godly wives. Meliboeus would have been driven by his own madness if Prudence had not directed him towards Christlike virtues. 

Finally, repentance is necessary for salvation. All Christians sin and fall, but a lifestyle of sin without repentance brings serious questions to an individual's walk with God.  

While some may find The Tale of Meliboeus to be boring, I think that this is hardly the case. The story maybe less colorful than some of the other Canterbury Tales. However, it leaves an impregnable message about forgiveness that is more important than entertainment. For this reason, I disagree with the modern consensus of this being one of the boring tales. 


                                                                                     Notes:


1*I noticed that unlike other Canterbury Tales, The Tale of Meliboeus is largely written in prose. I found that both odd and surprising. 

2* What was Chaucer's point here? Did he believe in indulgences? It should be remembered that Chaucer drew this story from another. Considering that this story was not an original work from Chaucer, how much authority does it represent of his views? Much or little? 


 

Saturday, May 15, 2021

A Review of The Canterbury Tales: The Shipman's Tale

 


                                                                          


                                                                           The Prologue: 


Near the beginning of the prologue, the parish priest asked the host to tell a story. Early on, the text makes reference to Lollardly, the reform movement in fourteenth century England that followed (if at times exaggerated) the attempts of John Wycliffe to reform the Roman Church. While I have always felt that Chaucer makes reference to Wycliffe's ideas in The Canterbury Tales, he does so explicitly here. The parson is suspected of being a Lollard and the shipman, also known as the sailor, responds briefly: 

"Nay, by my father's soul, that shall he not,''
Saide the Shipman; "Here shall he not preach, 
He shall no gospel close here nor teach. 
We all believe in the great God,'' quoth he. 
He would sowe some difficulty, 
Or springe cockle in our cleane corn.'' 

Was the Parson a Lollard? Who knows? Either way, The Canterbury Tales reflects the tension between Roman Catholics and the Proto-Protestants of Chaucer's day. Also, the prologue reveals just how concerned that the shipman was towards the parson. In the above quoted lines, the shipman is basically saying that the parson will bring trouble for the church because of his Lollardly. After accusing the parson of heresy however, things loosen up. I often find those that accuse others of heresy are fine with putting others on trial but have a double standard for themselves.  Anyhow, after the shipman makes reference to this, he goes on to tell his tale. 






                                                                             The Tale


The story opens about a merchant with a beautiful wife. His wife was fond of her pleasures in partying. The merchant had a friend that he claimed was his kindred. To a monk, he gave great loyalty. Fortunately, the monk also supported him equally as the two shared a great brotherhood. 
One day the merchant went out to buy some things. As this happened, the monk managed the property of his abbey. The merchant came by and drank with the monk. 
After these events, the wife one day came by the monk. She chats with him and he asks her why she looks ill. He tells her to tell him of her illness and distress. They both agreed to not tell others of their conversation. She says that she has suffered since being a wife. The monk confesses that he has always loved her above other women. He then tells her to tell him his grief. The merchant's wife responds and says that her husband is the worst man that she has ever known. 

''My dear love,'' quoth she, ''O my Dan John, 
Full life were me this counsel for to hide, 
But out it must, I may no more abide. 
My husband is to me the worste man
That ever was since that the world began; 
But since I am a wife, it sits not me...''

The merchant's wife does not end there. She describes the worth of a husband as inferior to a fly. She describes several things that she believes a wife should be including him being obedient to her. The monk promises to keep her secret and bring her the money that she has also requested of him. Immediately, the monk then passionately kissed her. 
After the wife returned to her husband, the merchant wanted to go to mass with her. Eventually, the merchant foolishly said the monk could have anything he owns. In fact, he does not want his friend, the monk, to take too little. The merchant went on to give the monk a vast amount of his money as he joined his ''friend'' for much drinking. 
The next day the merchant set out to Flanders. Meanwhile, the monk had sex with his wife. After all of this happened, the merchant returned home and continued his normal routine with his wife with no knowledge of her affair with the monk. After obtaining more riches, the merchant's wife gladly receives him. After attempting to sleep with his wife, she resists their intimacy. The tale ends with the merchant asking her to spend less money.  



                                                                         My Analysis: 



 

 

This is certainly one of the lesser well known of The Canterbury Tales. Going into reading it, I had no prior knowledge to the events or characters of this story. Chaucer drew likely from an Old French story for his own in The Shipman's Tale. I did find it odd that the story really had nothing to do with the work of a shipman. Ultimately, I found the story to begin better than how it ended. 


                                                                       




Certainly, an interesting read! As I finish up my reviews of The Canterbury Tales, I encourage all my readers to buy a copy of this classic. The Knight's Tale and The Nun's Priest's Tale are my personal favorites of all the stories. However, each one has been interesting in its own way. Finally, I feel that this story ended strange. Overall, I would not decree it as one of Chaucer's best literary moments. 





 The Shipman's Tale  may not be the most interesting of The Canterbury Tales, but I still think that it is necessary to read the full Canterbury Tales to truly grasp Chaucer's overall story. While this maybe off topic, I do feel that The Canterbury Tales leads a number of other literary works from the classical and medieval world that all medievalist need to read.  

Anyone that desires to study the Middle Ages must read The Aeneid by Virgil, The Metamorphoses by Ovid, Beowulf, The Divine Comedy by Dante Alighieri, The Consolation of Philosophy by Boethius, Confessions by Saint Augustine of Hippo, City of God by Saint Augustine of Hippo, Poetics by Aristotle, Everyman, Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, Pearl, Patience, The Song of Roland, The Romance of the Rose, The Whole Book of King Arthur and His Noble Knights of the Round Table by Thomas Malory, Eric and Enide by Chretien de Troyes, Lancelot by Chretien de Troyes, Perceval and Yvain by Chretien de Troyes, The History of the Kings of Britain by Geoffrey of Monmouth, The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, The Quest of the Holy Grail, and the Summary of Theology by Thomas Aquinas. While several other works also come to my mind's attention, I consider the titles that I have just now documented to be the most important to literary analyze for any medievalist. Of course, anything by Saint Augustine of Hippo or Geoffrey Chaucer I think would be beneficial for those interested in studying the literature and theology of the post-classical world. 





The study of Medieval literature begins and ends with Chaucer. While various works of Medieval literature are necessary reads to any medievalist, I argue for the superiority of Chaucer's works to understanding the literature of the Middle Ages over all else, except for Saint Augustine. While Augustine is an essential component to understand Medieval religion, the principle works of Chaucer and Dante are essential reads to anyone learning about the works of those medievals before us. 






References: Chaucer, Geoffrey. The Canterbury Tales. (1478). Books-A-Million. 

Friday, May 14, 2021

A Review of The Canterbury Tales: The Summoner's Tale

                                                 


                       




                                                                           The Prologue:







The prologue starts off with the summoner ready to strike out at the friar. He claims the friar has lied and brought suffering upon him. He tells a story about an angel that takes a friar to hell as the friar sees that none of his profession are there. However, the angel lets him know that a multitude of friars are in hell. The angel requests the devil to show the friar the many friars are in hell.

The prologue continues as the devil reveals twenty thousand friars to be in hell. The friar is left with an impregnable fear of hell afterwards. Chaucer then tells us to pray for this friar's soul. 







                                                                            The Tale: 


There was in Yorkshire a friar that both preached and begged. The friar in this tale serves people and will give them silly stories in return for food from them. This friar pretended to be all humble as he took advantage of others. 

The friar (not the one in the tale) meanwhile, accuses the summoner of lying. However, the host interrupts and tells the summoner to tell the whole tale. The summoner returns to the tale. 

By this point in the tale, the friar had come to a home where he was not wanted. The friar talks to a sick man and there and says that it would be hard for such a person as him to interpret scripture without the aid of a friar. Before I proceed, let me briefly interject the story for this point. 

Concerning the friar's remarks about the poor needing him to interpret scripture for them, I personally, feel like this is a reference again to Wycliffe's theology. Here, we see Chaucer possibly satirizing the Roman Catholic rejection of Sola scriptura while he favours the friar no more than he does the poor. Chaucer brings attention to the problems of people trusting in an infallible magisterium as the friar we already know, will misuse scripture for his personal power. Although many of the apologist from Rome will insist on the hierarchy never leading the flock astray, this story is a perfect example of what happens when people assume that the Roman Church's leadership and clergy will be faithful to the scriptures, when in fact, many of them have not been. Now, to return to the Summoner's Tale.

Chaucer gives an interesting description of the sick man giving a fart into the friar's hand: 

Amidde his hand he leet the frere a fart. 

Ther nis no capul, drawinge in a cart, 

That mighte have let a fart of swich a soune. 

The friar was driven out by the sick man's servants. No doubt, the friar became angry after he had hoped to get money from this sick man! Having went back to his lord, the lord tried to comfort the friar. The friar told him all that had previously happened. 

Last, the friar tried to gain sympathy from the lord's wife. Finally in the tale, the lord wakes up and sees the friar as the rotten character that he is. The story ends by the punishment of having the friar farted on. 



                                                                     My Analysis: 



An odd way to end no doubt! The Summoner's Tale is a reminder that corruption can come in any form, even in church clergy. I am not sure that the friar got exactly what he deserved at the end of the tale. However, I think that the prologue and story collectively imply that the friar was headed to hell. Of course, no greater condemnation awaits the wicked than damnation itself. 



A Review of The Canterbury Tales: The Cook's Tale

 


For this one I had to use the Books-A-Million edition of The Canterbury Tales from Sweetwater Press as this tale is not contained in the Barnes & Noble Classics edition. In fact, The Cook's Tale seems to be missing from most printed copies of The Canterbury Tales today. For whatever reason, very few modern copies of The Canterbury Tales include Geoffrey Chaucer's full work. 

The Cooke's Tale only goes on for about sixty lines. This story is quite short and very much a fabliau type of work. For those of you not aware, a fabliau was a genre in Medieval French literature that often- deployed crude humour. Of course, Chaucer's work though, is written in the English language. 

                                                                        

                                                                   The Prologue: 


After the Reeve had spoken the cook speaks of his peer having had a good conclusion to the last tale (The Reeve's Tale). The cook continues to praise him while saying how he himself will not have just any man over to his house. The cook then sets up a foundation for his own tale: 

"But God forbid that we should stinte here, 

And therefore if ye will vouchsafe to hear

A tale of me, that am a poore man, 

I will you tell as well as e'er I can

A little jape that fell in our city."

After the cook had spoken, the host encouraged him on. The cook then went on to tell his tale. 



                                                                         The Tale


There was a lively apprentice that dwelt in the city. He was a good dancer and very loveable. He loved the tavern and would often assemble with companions to hop and sing. This apprentice would often put his money into gambling in private street corners. Chaucer compares this character to a rotten apple. Eventually, his master wept as he let his apprentice go. In response, the apprentice spent all night being foolish. The story ends describing the foolishness of the cook and how his wife was a prostitute. Listen to the sad words of his master as he speaks of his former pupil: 

Of a proverb, that saith this same word;

Better is rotten apple of out of hoard, 

Than that it should rot all the remenant: 

So fares it by a riotous servant;

It is well lesse harm to let him pace,

Than he shend all the servants in the place. 

Therefore his master gave him a quittance, 

And bade him go, with sorrow and mischance, 

And thus this jolly prentice had his leve: 

Now let him riot all the night, or leave. 


                                                                      My Analysis: 


Being such a short story, The Cook's Tale does not cover much. The story has been left unfinished. Some scholars believe that Chaucer intended to finish it while others believe that he purposely left it the way it is. Whatever the case, the brief story that it is, is a rebuke to those that waste their life on gambling and immoral fun. Far too often, many throw away their potential as did the apprentice in this tale. 

The Cook's Tale was a good story. Where it falls short is its incompleteness. I think Chaucer was setting up a great story that I wish he had finished. 

Wealth gotten by vanity shall be diminished: but he that gathereth by labour shall increase. -Proverbs 13: 11





Saturday, May 1, 2021

A Review of The Canterbury Tales: The Friar's Tale

                               


                 


                                                       

                                                         The Prologue to The Friar's Tale: 



The friar looked upon the summoner with a scowl without coming out and criticizing him. The friar says that he will tell a story about a summoner. The summoner acts as if he does not care about the Friar telling a critical story of a summoner. In fact, he says that he will get even with the friar. The host puts an end to the squabble and tells the friar to tell his tale. 


                                                                           The Tale:



The tale opens about an Archdeacon that vigorously punished people for their sins. In fact, the Archdeacon even punished those who did not tithe faithfully. Well, it turns out that this Archdeacon also had a crooked summoner that assisted him. Indeed, Chaucer seems to allude to the summoner being worse than his master. The summoner is essentially a thief. 

In the tale, the summoner consults with the devil. He does this while planning on when he will prey on an old widow. He and the devil converse for a while and the devil speaks of his dark magician work. The devil describes how he makes use of other bodies, even dead ones, for him to enter and deceive. After playing a trick on a man in town with the devil's help, the summoner turns his attention again on the old woman. 

Chaucer describes the old woman through the words of the summoner as one that would rather die than giver money. The summoner threatens the woman with excommunication if she does not come out of her house. The old woman cries for charity as he demands her money or her excommunication. Despite lies from the summoner and the devil to coerce her into answering the door to them, the old woman never lets them in. Afterwards, the devil says he will take the summoner down with him into hell. Even the crooked friar that tells the tale, feels pity on what came for the summoner in his eternal damnation. The friar ends the tale invoking all of us to pray that God deliver us from the great torments of hell: 


Thogh that I mighte a thousand winter telle, 

The peyne of thilke cursed hous of helle. 





                                                                     Final Thoughts: 




The Friar's Tale may not be the most fascinating of The Canterbury Tales but it leaves us with one of the most important messages of all of them: the devil is out for our souls. This story also reflects the high abuse of power that was growing at an alarming rate in the Medieval Roman Catholic Church. All Christians, even Protestants, should recognize though how easy it is for any false teachers to arise in any church and coerce others into false doctrine. Ultimately, The Friar's Tale is a reminder that the wicked will pay for their evil in the pit that awaits them (Isaiah 24: 17). 

Though hand join in hand, the wicked shall not be unpunished: but the seed of the righteous shall be delivered. -Proverbs 11: 21






A Review of The Canterbury Tales: The Canon's Yeoman's Tale

 


                                                                          Part One: 


After the prologue to the tale, the first part of the tale begins. The yeoman describes his poor condition through several lines of poetic verse. He speaks of a cleric (possibly the canon?) that had told him how joyful it is for the poor to see their friends suffer. In other words, the cleric wishes to justify his own condition by making one that is poor look like that is an admirable position to be in. 

Later, after the yeoman has described a number of materials, he says:

A! nay! lat be; the philosophres stonon, ....

The Philosopher's Stone? It made me wonder if J. K. Rowling was inspired by the yeoman's words for her book, Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone. Of course, this would be no surprise. Even today, The Canterbury Tales continues to influence many works of literature. Likewise, the philosopher's stone was a famous mythical substance from Medieval Times. 


                                                                             Part Two:


The yeoman begins by describing a deceitful canon. This canon, we are told, lied so much that it cannot be written down. At the same time, the yeoman makes clear that are bad people in all professions. Additionally, the yeoman recommends to all to remove any Judas figure out of their lives. 

The yeoman tells us that a priest lent some money to a canon. The canon of course, seems to have had no intentions of paying back what he was owed. Chaucer goes so far as to even compare the canon to the devil. The canon essentially tricks the priest as to the values of the coals that the canon takes from him. The priest became totally deceived by the canon and the canon took all opportunity to use the priest to help himself cheat in gaining riches. The canon deceives by his wand which he uses on the coal. 

The canon continued to keep his villainy secret. He has the priest not tell others about his own taking of others money. Eventually though, the priest began to be suspicious of the canon. Unfortunately, it was too late. The canon fled. The story essentially ends after the canon flees and we are left with Chaucer quoting famous tales about the philosopher's stone. 


                                                                     Final Thoughts


Personally, this is one of my lesser favorites of The Canterbury Tales. While the references to the philosopher stone is interesting, I though this tales was much less colorful than some of the other ones. Nevertheless, the theme of being deceived by those we foolishly trust is always a reminder to be wise as serpents and as innocent as doves (Matthew 10: 16). Furthermore, The Canon's Yeoman's Tale is a reminder that even those working with the church can be deceptive. 

Go your ways: behold, I send you forth as lambs among wolves. -Luke 10: 3 (KJV).