Wednesday, September 14, 2022

Medieval Philosophy Matters




 Recently, I finished The Proslogion by Anselm of Canterbury. In it, Anselm uses reason to argue for the existence of God. For me, this is one of my favorite works to have come out of the Middle Ages. Hopefully, I will discuss more about it in a future post. 

While many today, see theology and philosophy as two separate disciplines, this was not the case for many in the twelfth-century. Indeed, many medieval philosophers saw their ideas as being in harmony with the Bible (though sometimes opposed by the church itself). As the university generally protected its people's freedom of speech, some church officeholders such as Martin Luther were able to challenge the status quo more than those outside of its setting.  





In general, all that we believe comes from a worldview. Whether or not we claim to believe in the existence of God, what we believe about the authority of religion, and how we perceive the afterlife is all reflected in our worldview. If our worldview is not based on the Bible, then it's based on something else; another religious work, one's culture, or one's upbringing. The Bible was the foundation for all of what those in the Middle Ages believed about both matter and time; this was even the case for illiterate peasants who learned Bible stories from the artwork in medieval churches. 

For many in the Middle Ages, the works of Augustine of Hippo were foundational to their theological understandings. His Confessiones (Confessions), for example, was important for its bluntness about his penitence over sin. De civitate Dei contra Paganos (The City of God), however, defended Christendom against accusations from the pagans in Rome who blamed Christianity for the former empire's downfall. De Trinitate (On the Trinity), likewise, served as a reminder to the orthodox communities of the many threats to true Christianity across the known world. Finally, in The Enchiridion (Faith, Hope, and Charity), Augustine defended God's predestination of men to salvation against some of the Semi-Pelagian groups that were at odds with Catholic Christianity. As someone who has read more than five of Augustine's works, I can personally testify to his great influence also on my own life. 

Many of us have heard of the Summa Theologica. We know that Thomas Aquinas was among the best of Medieval scholastics. However, fewer of us are familiar with his Contra Errores Graecorum. In this latter work, Aquinas wrote both against the Greek Orthodox Christians and the Muslims. While Aquinas was arguably more gentle in his dialogues than some, he reflected a growing divide between both western and eastern Christians that had been building for centuries. 

While many of the medievals differed from each other on particular points of doctrine such as what happens at mass, when is just war right, and whether or not the Virgin Mary was immaculate, they universally held to the belief that Christianity is the only way to God. Peter the Venerable, for instance, did not believe that Muslims worship the one true God as he explained in Against the Saracens*1. Likewise, the Council of Florence later dogmatically taught that all those who leave this life without water baptism shall be lost forever. 





According to Oxford historical theologian and scholar Alister Mcgrath*2, medieval theologians believed that scripture was the highest of all authorities. Indeed, because of this, many of them intended to base their views off of the Bible. Certainly, they knew that all other authorities are sinking sand and will fade with time (Ecclesiastes 1:14, Romans 12:2). Scripture, on the other hand, though, is forever (1 Peter 3:21). 

Whether or not we agree with the medievals, understanding their worldview helps us to understand them. For example, if we wish to learn more about twelfth-century England, then reading the theological writings of Anselm of Canterbury will enlighten us to common thoughts of that time. Knowing Medieval Philosophy also helps us to understand both the culture and the art of the era. One of the interesting particulars of historical studies is that both an Evangelical Christian and a professing atheist*3 can differ from each other's worldviews and yet still study the past as historians. Truly, even people whose ideas are nothing alike to each other, are able to mutually construct facts together about what it meant to live in Medieval Times. 

1*For this compilation of several of his works, see the volume Church Fathers: Medieval Continuation Against the Saracens translated by Irven M. Resneck. 

2* See Reformation Thoughts: An Introduction. 

3* According to scripture, there are no true atheists (Jeremiah 11:20, Psalm 44:21, Romans 1:19).


Friday, July 15, 2022

Ten Essential Works of Medieval Literature in the English Language





I have not read all of the following titles. I hope to do so soon, however.


Sir Gawain and the Green Knight

The Canterbury Tales by Geoffrey Chaucer

Everyman

Beowulf*

Piers Plowman by William Langland

The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle

Caedmon's Hymn

Le Morte d'Arthur by Thomas Malory

The Book of Margery Kempe by Margery Kempe

Pearl


You may ask why these titles I have chosen? Well, it's hard to imagine Medieval literature without Chaucer. While several of his works are significant to understanding the literary world that Medieval people imagined, The Canterbury Tales is fundamental. Then again, so are the Arthurian stories. Whether it is from Malory or the Pearl Poet, we can't separate the tales of King Arthur and his knights from most Medieval literature. Lastly, works like Everyman and Piers Plowman bear witness to the theological worldview of many people throughout Medieval times. 

While the works of Virgil, Ovid, Dante, and Boccaccio were composed in languages other than English, their books are nevertheless helpful to understanding Medieval literature as their stories impacted the written works of Old and Middle English. The Bible, Dante, and Ovid are three essential sources for understanding medieval literature, according to C. S. Lewis. As someone who has read all three, I agree with him. 




*Some scholars consider Old English literature distinct from Medieval literature.









Saturday, May 21, 2022

The Relation of the Arts to Christianity in the Middle Ages

   



For my previous thoughts on the roles of the arts in medieval Christianity, see the following post: 

https://themedievalist.blogspot.com/2022/03/the-relation-of-arts-to-theology-in.html       


                                                                     

                                                                        


                                                                    

                                                

                                                                     Introduction: 


Christianity informed the Middle Ages of much of what it was about. Unlike some other eras in history that preceded it and came after it, almost all Medieval literature and art is about Biblical themes or Christianity in some way. As discussed in my previous post, the theologian Hugh of Saint Victor believed that both the philosophy and the arts could be used to support theology. 

                                                                        


                                                                   Medieval Art:


The arts greatly defined the theological characteristics of the Middle Ages. For example, the great use of stone in Notre Dame personifies (in my view at least) the seriousness of the cathedral's place in Paris. However, I want to discuss more than just my interpretation of the medievals' works. 

While I appreciate the study of Byzantine and Islamic art, I prefer the study of the western art of the Middle Ages. Furthermore, I'm going to be emphasizing aspects of the later medieval art only in this post. While I appreciate Early Medieval and Romanesque art, the cathedrals and illuminated manuscripts of the Gothic and the fourteenth-century eras of art are in my view, the best of post-classical art until the Renaissance. In particular, I am fascinated by the powerful presence of the Gothic cathedrals which in many ways, demonstrated as much influence as the local castle in the High Middle Ages. 


                                                                             


   



Speaking of Gothic architecture, medievalist and art historian Marilyn Stokstad wrote, ''Truly, Gothic churches became the glorious jeweled houses of God, evocations of the heavenly Jerusalem. They were also glowing manifestations of Christian doctrine, and invitations to faithful living, encouraging worshipers to follow in the footsteps of the saints whose lives were frequently featured in the windows of Gothic churches. Stained glass soon became the medium of monumental painting (Stokstad, 491).''

I could not agree more with Stockstad. Look at the Scenes From Genesis in the Good Samaritan Window of Notre Dame's cathedral. In this masterpiece, you will observe Biblical stories across the stained glass. The artwork was not made by the medievals simply because they loved to make art, but because art was a means of demonstrating a theological truth. For example, in Scenes from Genesis, Adam and Eve are found to be nude at the top right corner of the painting. They are looking up with fearful faces as they are being judged for their sin. This reflects the importance of the doctrine of original sin in Medieval Christianity. To those living in the Gothic era of Medieval Art (twelfth-thirteenth centuries), the fear of God's judgment upon them for their sins was central to their faith and their religious practices. 






Of course, the use of art within the church was controversial at times. Abbot Sugar, one of the masterminds behind Saint-Denis Cathedral, was for the use of art in monasteries for the purpose of monks growing in their faith. Saint Bernard of the Cistercian order had more reservations about such works, however. To him, it was better that monasteries be more simple and simply focus on God without art being a distraction. Whoever's view one agrees with here, both sides had the same goal in mind: to glorify the Creator while simultaneously promoting strict religious adherence. 

On a similar note, I would like to mention the fact that the early medievals were afraid of breaking the second commandment. Because they did not want God to be violated through false imagery, many portrayed Christ as vague in their art (something that the Renaissance would not imitate later). To the early medievals, the second commandment did not mean what it would later mean to the sixteenth-century puritans. The latter group had a clear-cut understanding of the second commandment: all images and works of art about Christ are wrong. The early medievals though did not see abstract and one-dimensional art as violating the second commandment. Indeed, the concept of all images and pictures violating the second commandment was largely unknown to Christian history before the Reformation. While there had been Carologians who took issue with the Byzantine icons in the Early Medieval period, this does not mean that they were against all works of art about Christ. In fact, there had been works of art on the catacombs concerning Christ since the persecution of Christians in the early centuries. Many of the Reformed churches of the sixteenth century made a radical breach from the past by removing all works of art from churches.*1

One of my favorite aspects of Medieval art is The Rose Window and Lancets from Chartres Cathedral. This beautiful illumination from 1230-1235 A.D. is truly a piece of beauty. Imagine the sunshine flowing through the glass as it gives to us the light of heaven. Likewise, no matter the time of day, those standing below the window could look above and be grateful for the saints praying for them. The Rose Window was also a reminder that this world was not the beginning nor the end of everything. Eternity (as depicted here), was either with God and His holy saints or with the damned in the fires of destruction. 





There is much to be observed from The Rose Window. I love the references to the Holy Spirit as the dove throughout this stained glass window. Looking at the painting, I also admire admiration for France as shown in the Fleur-de-Lions throughout. Last, but certainly not least, the blessed Virgin Mary is in the center of the picture as she holds the Babe Savior. To me, this is one of the great masterpieces of the Gothic era. 

As a partial result of the Italian Renaissance, many in the fourteenth-century came to desire a return to the literature and art forms of the classical world. Petrarch's love sonnets about a married woman named ''Laura'' reflected a change in literature from the previous religious Christendom. More and more, writings and paintings reflected the loss of influence in the church. Chaucer's The Canterbury Tales, for example, depicts corrupt clergy throughout its stories. 

Nevertheless, as the Italian Renaissance began, some countries were certainly less impacted by it than others. While Chaucer drew from Italian and French writers, England as a whole remained quite medieval. The Hours of Jeanne d'Evreux depicted Judas Iscariot betraying His Lord. Likewise, while Chaucer satirized church leaders, this does not mean that he was opposed to orthodox Christianity. 






There was hardly a breach in fourteenth-century Medieval English art from the previous centuries of England's history. Much of the artwork in England still reflected traditional concepts as had been betrayed in earlier Medieval art. One of the best examples of this would be The Opus Anglicanum. This work of art was made from pictorial needlework and became popular throughout Europe. It was often used during Mass. 








                                                                      Renaissance Art: 


The fourteenth-century was significantly different for England than it had been for Italy. For the former, the Middle Ages had not yet passed. For the latter however, a new era had already begun. 

The Renaissance brought on many challenges to previous philosophical beliefs of the Middle Ages. For example, after the Black Plague, less artwork and literature came to reflect Christianity as it had previously. Furthermore, many Renaissance philosophers came to challenge widely accepted theological dogmas of their age. At the same time, however, this was still a Christian era. Though there was more emphasis on secular themes and nude figures than there had been previously, many artists and writers of the Renaissance still portrayed the blessed virgin and her Son as gloriously as they had always been demonstrated in past works of art. 





Below, I have copied some of my work for one of my previous assignments from ARTS 204: Medieval Art. Now that I have finished this course, I can say that I was very pleased to study this topic through Liberty University's online programs. 

Both Madonna Enthroned with Angels and Prophets by Cimabue and Madonna Enthroned by Giotto are beautiful pictures. Each of these works was composed in the fourteenth century. Likewise, there are a lot of similarities between these two works of art. Both paintings contain golden backgrounds, both place the blessed virgin and her Babe Son as the central focus, and both show holy persons surrounding Mary and Christ. However, there are also some significant differences between the two. 

Giotto's Madonna Enthroned is often considered the first work of the Renaissance. Whereas it shows both angels and saints surrounding the holy queen on her left and right, Cimabue's Madonna Enthroned with Angels and Prophets shows only angels on both sides of the Mother of God while demonstrating saints below her. While both reflect the divine, Giotto also colors the halos behind Mary and Christ more than Cimbaue's portrayal. Perhaps even more striking, however, is the fact that Mary and Christ sit within a covered throne only in Giotto's painting. 

Pictures of the Virgin Mary with her Son were frequent in Latin Churches since at least the thirteenth century. Reflecting Byzantine styles, these pictures reflected the importance of Mariology to the medievals. The Nativity was central to the medieval narrative of Christ, and it would only be natural that they should pay tribute to the virgin Mary considering her contribution to this story. 





I enjoyed the study of Giotto and Cimabue's works of art. As is the case for me always, I feel illuminated by the study of the Middle Ages. 

One of the things I noticed most about these paintings from Giotto and Cimabue was their recurrent use of bright colors in their portraits. It reminded me of how the later Renaissance movements would substantially use this technique. In short, I began to wonder, did Giotto and Cimabue influence the forthcoming artists in this regard? 




                                                                     Conclusion: 

The medievals and their renaissance descendants left quite the legacy of art for us to learn from their examples. Their meticulous attention to detail is admirable. In honor of them, I end this post with a poem: 


As the Saints do Sing, 

Angelic art we do bring, 

The troubadours play for love, 

but the pilgrims turn to heaven above. 



1* It should be noted that there is debate about why the Reformed Churches removed images in churches. However, that is not the purpose of this post. 


References: 

Stokstad, Marilyn. Art History Volume One. (2011). Pearson. 

Tuesday, April 12, 2022

Why The Chronicles of Narnia is the Best Series Ever

 


Over the years, The Chronicles of Narnia by C. S. Lewis, The Lord of the Rings by J. R. R. Tolkien, and Harry Potter by J. K. Rowling have been among the leading contenders for the most respected fantasy series ever. Each series of books has its own value and is worth reading. I personally prefer Narnia over the other two, however. 

Some years ago, I read The Hobbit by J. R. R. Tolkien. While I enjoyed this work, I have come to appreciate it more over time. When I read The Lord of the Rings by J. R. R. Tolkien, I immediately came to see it as superior to The Hobbit. I have loved Tolkien's stories of Middle-Earth since I was young, and The Lord of the Rings left an impression on me not only for its epic story of Frodo and Sam but also for its beautiful literary status. The Lord of the Rings may very well be the best-written work of the twentieth century, and for that reason alone, it is a true classic of English literature.



Lately, I've been reading J. K. Rowling's Harry Potter series, and I have enjoyed each of the books. The Philosopher's Stone and The Prisoner of Azkaban are among my favorite works of the series. Rowling has a charm to her writing style, and her popularity among fans resonates strongly because of her remarkable talent as a writer. The Harry Potter series is arguably one of the best-written series in the twenty-first century. Rowling's stories have had a significant influence on modern culture, and the large fandom of the books comes as no surprise given each novel's well-written status. 



Why Narnia, then? Why do I prefer C. S. Lewis's series over Harry Potter or Lord of the Rings? I have three points to argue in favor of The Chronicles of Narnia being superior to the other two literary works. Below, I have written an essay on this topic: 






                                                                  Introduction: 


C. S. Lewis was both a great philosopher and a literary genius. His Christian views informed him about everything he did, and he wove his knowledge of scripture into his writings. His ability to transform both theology and good story-telling into literature reflected a rare genius on his part. Additionally, Lewis's knowledge of both philosophy and medieval literature allowed him to write not only books about past literature but also to write new literature of his own. When he wrote The Chronicles of Narnia, he was not writing it simply as a good novelist, but also as a brilliant literary scholar. In my view, by the writing of these books, C. S. Lewis achieved a higher level of success in the literary tradition than either J. R. R. Tolkien or J. K. Rowling. The superiority of The Chronicles of Narnia over both Harry Potter and The Lord of the Rings is attributed to its theological elements, its roots in Medieval literature, and its enchanting storytelling. 


                          Part 1: The Theological Implications of The Chronicles of Narnia


The Chronicles of Narnia by C. S. Lewis was influenced by the author's Christian faith. In the first published novel, Edmund takes from the Turkish delight given to him by the White Witch (Chapter IV). Despite the fact that Edmund knew better, his pride guided him against his family. In fact, he was hardly innocent as the White Witch tempted him. He wanted to hear the flattery that she gave him. 

In the same way, many of us often desire the wants of this life that are not good for us. From sin, we find more pleasure in what we want at the moment than what will keep us satisfied long-term. Edmund's fall resembles the fall of Adam and Eve in Genesis 3. Like them, he took of something that seemed pleasurable at the moment---but which brought on detrimental effects for everyone else. 

Perhaps the closest value to Christianity in the Narnia books is the sacrifice of Aslan. The great lion gives his life in Edmund's place (Chapter XIV) so that Edmund won't have to be killed by the witch. While nothing in literature can truly parallel the work that Jesus Christ did, The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe do as good as a children's book can do for this. Throughout the whole novel, Aslan is portrayed as a great and just lion---tributes which adds to the sadness that we all feel when he gives his life on the stone table. As we read the book, we feel moved by Lucy and Susan's tears that the great lion has fallen and we are (hopefully) reminded of the dismay that the disciples felt when Christ passed from them. Near the end of The Voyage of the Dawn Treader, Reepicheep leaves us in awe of Aslan's country. Though the brave mouse loved his friends, he ultimately desired to be with Aslan.  

The Chronicles of Narnia has as much or more to teach adults about the values of Christianity as they do for children. Perhaps if we read them frequently, we would learn to come to Christ as children (Matthew 18: 3) just as many of the children came before Aslan throughout the series. Obedience does not necessarily require great knowledge, but it means us trusting in God even when we don't understand everything about His will and our purpose. Likewise, Jill Pole did not realize her purpose when Aslan gave her a task (Chapter II of The Silver Chair) yet she did as he said. Perhaps if we spent less time questioning why God wants us to do certain things and instead actually do them, we would waste a lot less time. 



                               Part II: The Roots of Medieval literature in The Chronicles of Narnia



Many readers who love C. S. Lewis and his writings are unaware of the impact that Medieval literature had on his stories. While Medievalism also greatly influenced Tolkien, I have always seen Narnia as more resembling the world of the High and Late Middle Ages whereas I have seen Middle-Earth as greatly drawn from the Anglo-Saxon world of the Middle Ages. When it comes to history, Tolkien and Lewis's works easily surpass Rowling's. Though the Harry Potter series is entertaining to read, they lack the imagination of a fantasy world akin to the legends of King Arthur and Merlin which both Narnia and Middle-Earth give. 

To me, The Horse and His Boy closely resemble aspects of crusading legends from the Medieval era. As the Calormans attempt to take Queen Susan and force her into a marriage with their prince, I sense that Lewis was familiar with the crusades, and not just their history, but the accounts that some of them left for us to read of their expeditions. As an interesting note, the crusades are actually mentioned near the beginning of Prince Caspian.  

In The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe, C. S. Lewis tells us a story about Aslan's death that may resemble the atonement of Christ for many Christians. Interestingly enough, Lewis was hardly ignorant of the doctrine of the incarnation. Having written a preface to Athanasius's On the Incarnation, he knew well that this doctrine was central to Medieval theology. Although Aslan does not transform his body into another form (except in Voyage of the Dawn Treader) the idea of an incarnation is still somewhat within the first published book. For example, Aslan (like Christ) did not simply reign from high heaven and look down on Narnia. The great lion walked among the sons of Adam and the daughters of Eve. Aslan knew Peter, Susan, Edmund, and Lucy just as Christ knows the children of God (Galatians 3: 26). 

Finally, the ideas of chivalry and romance are found throughout the Narnia books. As an illustration, Peter saves his sister, Susan, from a great wolf in The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe (Chapter XII). Likewise, Ramandue's daughter and King Caspian together reflect a traditional romance in The Voyage of the Dawn Treader (Chapter XIV) similar to one that a reader would find in Medieval literature. 

The Medieval feel of the Narnia books is nothing the avid Lewis fan should miss. When one studies the Narnia books next to the works of the Middle Ages, it would be difficult to be blind to all the similarities between them. As a result, Lewis left us with stories with strong allegory and solid theology just as Chaucer and Malory did for their respective eras. 



                        Part III: The enchanting storytelling of The Chronicles of Narnia


There is a reason beyond theology and its shared qualities with other past works of literature that the Narnia books are so loved. Many of us simply read C. S. Lewis simply because his stories are magical to us. Like Lucy in the wardrobe, we are enchanted by the thought of going into another world. Additionally, we long to have someone near us who we can laugh with and cry with just like Lucy does with Aslan. 

In the second chapter of The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe, Lewis leaves us wondering what the Faun's intent really is. Is he truly sorry that he has worked for the White Witch? Or is it that Mr. Tumnus only speaks regretfully in front of Lucy so as to trick her into returning to his home? Examples like these, are what keep us on the edge as we read good stories. Lewis knew how to keep the reader intrigued enough not to just mark the page and never finish the book. Again and again, the author of Narnia keeps us longing for more of shadowlands. 



                                                                     Conclusion: 


While The Lord of the Rings is a better literary work than The Chronicles of Narnia, in many ways, I prefer the latter. The Narnia books may not have the language of Tolkien or Milton, yet they make great reads and leave us with a joyful feeling. Likewise, The Chronicles of Narnia is so enriched with Christian themes that essentially nothing save Confessions by Saint Augustine of Hippo, The Pilgrim's Progress by John Bunyan, and Everyman be possibly more Christian literary than it. 

Personally, I would cautious Christians about the Harry Potter series for reasons that are not mentioned in this article. Narnia and Middle-Earth are great Christian fantasies for all who hold to the Christian faith. 

There is much that all of us can enjoy about The Chronicles of Narnia. I love these books just as I always have. As I have written this, it has given me the desire to read these classics again. 











The English Reformation and Transubstantiation

 


                                                                      Introduction: 

Transubstantiation was an important theological position of the Roman Catholic Church. It taught that at the consecration of the elements, the bread and wine used for the Eucharist, become the Body and Blood of Christ. While taught by the Fourth Lateran Council, this position remained controversial---especially during the later Protestant Reformation. 

Before we understand why Transubstantiation was controversial though, it is important that we examine the Eucharist as it was understood and practiced in the early church. By understanding the role of the Eucharist in early Christianity, it can help critique later positions that developed in Christendom. 

To begin with, many early Christians took the words of Jesus literally in Mark 14: 22-24. Likewise, they understood the Eucharist to give grace to those who received it worthily. The latter position was based on their understanding of Paul's warning to those who take from the table unworthily (1 Corinthians 11: 23-25). The Romans who practiced the gods of the empire, however, could not understand why Christians desired the flesh of Jesus. To them, the Christians must be cannibals. 



Although some modern evangelical theologians have interpreted the early church fathers to teach memorialism, this is a misreading of the church fathers. While another post could be written all for the topic alone, I strongly believe (as do many historians and theologians) that the vast majority of early church fathers taught the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist. Where many evangelicals go wrong is that they will read a passage from scripture or early Christianity that may speak of remembering Christ. However, even Roman Catholics believe that the Mass remembers what Christ did. It is a logical fallacy to assume from a text in scripture or church history that because something says about remembering Christ at the Lord's Table that it means nothing else than that. For example, though many early church fathers describe the Eucharist as being a memorial towards their Savior, they never say that it is simply that. Indeed, had Paul the Apostle believed that Jesus was merely speaking in parables it is hard to imagine why he would have understood the Eucharist to be so serious (1 Corinthians 11: 23-25). On the contrary, some of the earliest Christians spoke of the Eucharist being a ''sacrifice'' and how they ate the flesh of Christ: 

''A marvellous thing in truth, that God rained manna for our fathers. Yet they who ate that bread died in the wilderness. But the Bread which thou recievest, that living Bread which came down from heaven, supplieth the substance of life eternal: it is the Body of Christ''-Saint Ambrose of Milan (Baverstock, A. H. The Eucharistic Year, 1930, p. 91).

''When the sacrifice is being offered, and Christ becometh our sacrifice when thou seest the curtains drawn at the doors (of the iconostasis) consider that high heaven is drawn down, and the Angels descend''-Saint John Chrysostom ( p. 96). 

No question, the Eucharist was highly regarded by the early church fathers. That said, I think that there are strong reasons to believe that the church did not historically teach Trent's dogmatic understanding of Transubstantiation. Among these reasons, it is important to recognize that the early Christians did not universally believe that Christ's literal Body and Blood are present during Communion (though nearly of all them did agree with the belief of His real presence). 

''Thou hast prepared meat for them. A spiritual meat is understood. He saith that this hath been prepared, since before the foundation of the world was fore-ordained the mystery of Christ, who is the living Bread coming down from heaven and giving life to the world.'' -Origen of Alexandria (p. 95). 

So before we evaluate the doctrine of transubstantiation in light of the English Reformation, let me summarize the above information that I have provided. Early Christianity took the Eucharist to be Christ's Body and Blood (some literal, others spiritual, though hardly none understood it as just memorial). The Eucharist was central to early Christian practice and would serve as a foundation for much of later Medieval Christianity. 


                                        II. Transubstantiation in Medieval Christianity


The real presence of Christ in the Eucharist was widely accepted long after the first three centuries of Christianity. The fact that it was hardly challenged is further evidence of its orthodoxy. This does not mean, however, that the idea of Transubstantiation was universally accepted across Christendom. 

The doctrine of Transubstantiation was not formally taught by a church council until 1215. Even then, the Fourth Lateran Council defined it in ways that would be less offensive to Protestants than how the Council of Trent would define it in the sixteenth century. For example, the Fourth Lateran Council never taught that Christ's Divinity and Soul are present within the Eucharist. Despite the fact that some Protestants may have other issues with the Lateran Council's understanding of the Eucharist, their objections would be mild compared to what Trent would later teach: 

''There is one Universal Church of the faithful outside of which there is absolutely no salvation. In which there is the same priest and sacrifice, Jesus Christ, whose body and blood are truly contained in the sacrament of the altar under the forms of bread and wine; the bread being changed (transubstantiation) by divine power into the body, and the wine into the blood, so that to realize the mystery of unity we may receive of Him what He has received of us.'' -Fourth Lateran Council, Can I.  

During the Counter-Reformation, the Council of Trent made Transubstantiation dogma: 

''If anyone denies that in the sacrament of the most Holy Eucharist are contained truly, really and substantially the body and blood together with the soul and divinity of our Lord Jesus Christ, and consequently, the whole Christ, but says that He is in it only as in a sign, or figure or force, let him be anathema.'' -Council of Trent, Thirteenth Session, Canon 1. 

Essentially, the Council of Trent ordered for the excommunication of anyone who denied its teaching. It also taught doctrines such as the Divinity and Soul of Christ being present in Holy Communion despite the fact that no one in church history taught these teachings for the first eight centuries of the church's existence. 

But what evidence is there to show that Trent's understanding of Transubstantiation was never taught in the church's history. Surely, after all, Rome would not force a dogmatic teaching concerning something that had not always been taught? Think again. 

                                                        III. The English Reformation 


Among all of the theological differences between Catholics and Protestants during the Reformation era, the debate over the Mass was among the most heated. For at the core of Transubstantiation was a reliance upon the priesthood of the Catholic Church for salvation. This is because Rome understood only ordained clergy as having the authority to consecrate the bread and wine into the Body and Blood of Christ. To the Roman Catholic, pastors and priests not ordained by a bishop were invalid. As a result, Rome believed that many Protestants who followed Protestant Reformers who had no apostolic succession, could not obtain absolution for their mortal sins. While many of the reformers were former Catholic priests, not all of them were. For example, John Calvin had never been ordained by a bishop. Furthermore, few bishops sided with the cause of the Reformation. This in turn, would mean that former Catholic priests could not carry on priestly powers to their successors. 

In England, things were a little bit different than elsewhere in Europe. For example, many clergy within the Church of England came to accept at least some of the Protestant ideas after Henry VIII's breach from Rome in 1534. Nevertheless, like those in Continental Europe, those supporting the English Reformation took great issues with Transubstantiation. Indeed, Thomas Cranmer considered the debate over the Mass to be the most important issue of the Reformation. 

Contrary to the claims of many Catholic apologists, transubstantiation was not the universally accepted position concerning the Eucharist before the Reformation. The supporters of Rome have done a good job at portraying the Reformation as a radical movement that abolished the historic practice of viewing the Eucharist as the Body and Blood of Christ---so they say. Interestingly enough, many before the sixteenth century had denied Transubstantiation. Among theologians who denied it included William of Ockham, John Wycliffe, and Jan Huss. 

Those in England during the Elizabethan era were aware of the fact that not all of Christendom had taught Transubstantiation in past centuries. Especially before the Fourth Lateran Council, there had been several different views concerning the Holy Eucharist in the early Middle Ages. 

Archbishop Matthew Parker approved of The Thirty-Nine Articles which denied Transubstantiation in canon XXVIII. Parker, who was an avid reader of Anglo-Saxon literature, looked to the English Church before the Norman Conquest as a type of a pre-Anglican Church. He was aware of how many practices in England had changed as a result of the Norman Conquest. Among these changes had included the English Church coming more under the thumb of the papacy, the gradual suppression of the Bible in English (though there were some examples of Middle English translations before Wycliffe), and the gradual acceptance of Roman doctrine. From a sermon by Aelfric, Abbot of Eynsham, Parker felt that the ancient English church had never taught Transubstantiation at all. I encourage you to read the sermon here: 

https://quod.lib.umich.edu/e/eebo/A26478.0001.001/1:3?rgn=div1;view=fulltext&fbclid=IwAR1dtrLA43fspsbiK7wCzg8u21pOHTr60P7xIqB2HheNK3a64ILPYadlX7k

                                                                   IV: Conclusion


Transubstantiation does not equate with believing in the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist. When one reads the early church fathers, for example, one should not so easily conclude that they taught Transubstantiation because many of them understood the Eucharist to be the literal Flesh and Blood of Christ. Furthermore, while some of the church fathers did describe a change of elements as having taken place at Mass, none of the ancient councils ever held Transubstantiation as dogma. Likewise, when it was taught at the Fourth Lateran Council in 1215, the medieval council did not have the same understanding of it as did Trent. 

At the same time, I look forward to hearing counter-arguments from my Roman Catholic friends. My issue with Trent's dogma of Transubstantiation is less with the ideas that this doctrine proposes than that of it being a dogma for all Christians to believe. On the other hand, though, I believe that Transubstastion is trying to explain the miracle at the Eucharistic table which no one can perfectly explain. I prefer to see the Eucharist more as a mystery, at least as concerns dogma. While in my view, good Christians can believe in Transubstantiation, it should not be dogma as Trent understood it. 

Further Sources: 

Baverstock, A. H. (1930). The Eucharistic Year. Morehouse Publishing. 

Haigh, Christopher. (1993). English Reformations: Religion, Politics, and Society under the Tudors. Clarendon Press. 

Ruud, J. (2006). Encyclopedia of Medieval Literature by Ja Ruud. Facts on File. 










Sunday, March 27, 2022

The relation of the Arts to Theology in Medieval Christianity: An Introduction

 


In many ways, the Middle Ages was the era of art and beauty. Some of the greatest works of literature were written during this era. Indeed, Chaucer, Dante, and Thomas Malory left timeless classics that have been read and enjoyed for generations. Likewise, even today, the architecture from the Romanesque and Gothic eras still intrigues those in western society. The influence of art, however, went far beyond literature. No doubt, even many theologians appreciated its value. 

Hugh of St. Victor (11th-12th centuries) was a canon in the Catholic Church. Influenced by Saint Augustine of Hippo, he saw value in both philosophy and art. An important scholastic of the Middle Ages, he also believed that both the arts and philosophy can support theology. No doubt, his views were not rare. Medieval art reflected theological values through architecture, illuminated manuscripts, and Medieval stained glass windows. Certainly, I will discuss his views more soon. Additionally, I hope to discuss my love of illuminated manuscripts in future posts. 

As I have been taking a course in Medieval Art through Liberty University's programs, I have felt more inspired towards the study of the Crusades and the western Middle Ages than I have in years. For me, reading about the illuminated manuscripts, the frescoes of Byzantine art, and the architecture of the Islamic world, has continued to build my understanding of the Medieval experience. Indeed, the Bamberg Psalter reflects the Christian values of its era by its depiction of Judas betraying Jesus as described in the Biblical accounts. Likewise, reading about how the Eucharist was a central component of early Christianity has revised some of my earlier criticism of mainstream Evangelical Christianity---which has put the focus more on the preacher's performance behind the pulpit, than on the Body and Blood of Christ. 

I wish to discuss the relationship between Christianity and Medieval Art in my next posts. I have much to talk about. 

''God is the ultimate artist and we have the ability to make crafts of His workmanship. ''

-Joshua Dotson

Tuesday, March 1, 2022

A Review of Humility as described in The Four Loves by C. S. Lewis

 



As of late, I have greatly enjoyed reading The Four Loves by C. S. Lewis. I believe that there is much to spiritually learn from this work. As I continued reading the section on Affection in this book, I greatly admired the following passage: 

''In Jane Austen's novel, Emma intends that Harriet Smith should have a happy life; but only the sort of happy life which Emma herself has planned for her. My own profession-that of a university teacher-is in this way dangerous. If we are any good we must always be working towards the moment at which our pupils are fit to become our critics snd rivals. We should be delighted when it arrives, as the fencing master is delighted when his pupil can pink and disarm him. And many are (Lewis, p. 51, 1960).''

I felt gladdened by this passage as I see such humility from Lewis here. He doesn't desire to be the greatest- in fact, he wishes for his students to surpass him. Nor does he believe that he holds the pedestal that all else must live up to. This is amazing. Lewis demonstrates Christ to his readers by his lack of concern over being the best among men. 

As I read this passage, I prayed to God for such humility. I truly believe that we humans are most happy when we are most humble. Take away our pride and we are not defensive over ourselves. From our pride flows our defensive nature to protect ourselves from others seeing us less than how we wish to be seen, and by being defensive, our efforts become all about defending ourselves rather than loving others. Indeed, no man on earth can think of others if his pride consumes his thoughts. Pride actually bounds us from freedom. Only through Christ can our efforts be reversed from our sinful tendencies which somehow tell us that we are the standard of what everyone else should be.