Friday, September 22, 2023

Essay on Chivalry in Henry IV Part Two

 







Joshua Dotson


Professor Rice


English 333: Shakespeare


September 22, 2023


The Decline of Chivalry in Shakespeare’s Henry Fourth Part Two











      Shakespeare had an extensive knowledge of Medieval literature. His The Two Noble Kinsman is a retelling of Geoffrey Chaucer's The Knight's Tale. Likewise, the great English playwright knew Medieval history. While fictionalizing scenes and dialogue in his historical plays, he was certainly familiar with many contexts of the Medieval world. He knew much, indeed, about how the world of knighthood was changing in the setting of Henry IV, Part II. Chivalry was decaying. The once-orderly knighthood had shifted well since the time of Richard II. Indeed, it had already changed by Act Two, Scene One of the play. The reasons for this adjustment originated from the declining honor of knighthood, the conduct of John of Lancaster, and the complexity of a divided kingdom. 

     The honor of knighthood was in disarray by the time of the early fifteenth century, as recounted in Henry IV, Part II. In Act 4, Scene 2, for example, John of Falstaff is outspoken against Colevile, a fellow knight: “Well, then, Colevile is your name, a knight is your degree, and your place the Dale. Coleville shall be still your name, a traitor your degree, and the dungeon your place, a place deep enough so shall you be still Colevile of the Dale (Shakespeare, 4.2.4-7).” Later, the knight easily surrenders to him in the forest, also demonstrating a change from the once-respected Code of Chivalry. The once-glorious years of Richard II's rule before his overthrow at the hands of Henry Bolingbroke preceded this radical switch. Now, with the kingdom’s inability to recover from the successful revolt, Falstaff and his companions retain a flippant view of the previously respected institutions which had dwindled to nothing more than ragged men in dressed uniforms. Furthermore, even though Falstaff strikes fear in Colevile considering Falstaff's alleged murder of Hotspur at the Battle of Shrewsbury, the fact that the knight surrenders so easily to Falstaff is evidence of a declining knighthood in which more and more of the nobility fail to live up to the sense of honor and duty that their fathers once shared before them. 

     Additionally, the conduct of John of Lancaster plays an important role in Henry IV, Part II concerning the decline of knighthood. A son of Henry IV and a brother to Prince Hal, John's place is at the center of all the struggles occurring in the play. He ultimately mirrors a sense of honor, responding to the scandalous knight, “Now, Falstaff, where have you been all this while? When everything is ended, then you come. These tardy tricks of your will, on my life, One time or other break some gallows' back (Shakespeare,4.2.23-26).” In return, Falstaff responds, “I would be sorry, my lord, but it should be thus. I never knew yet rebuke and the check was the reward of valor (Shakespeare,4.2.26-27).” While John of Lancaster feels a sense of moral obligation to fight in battle for the kingdom's future, John of Falstaff is interested in attaining prizes without any work to first achieve them. In this scene, John is a symbol of the old knighthood, while Falstaff is an image of the new manhood. Indeed, the contrast between the two men also parallels the role of honor in the play. 

      Once upon a time, knights were perceived as worthy of honor, but this code devolved during the civil war between Henry IV and Prince Hal, the king's son. Indeed, Hal's war against his father produces scandal in the kingdom as morality declines, with men having little interest in upholding the former ideals of chivalry. Falstaff explains the cause of war, “Herof comes it that Prince Harry is valiant, for the cold blood he did naturally inherit of his father he hath, like lean, sterile, and bare land, manured, husbanded, and tilled with the excellent endeavor of drinking good and good store of fertile sherries, that he is become very hot and valiant. If I had a thousand sons, the first human principle I would teach them should be to forswear thin potations and to addict themselves to sack (Shakespeare, 4.2. 104-112).” In these final lines of the scene, Falstaff informs the audience of his admiration of Prince Hal, who squanders all in his pathway. Knighthood, as it was once known, has clearly died. When Falstaff says, “Herof comes it that Prince Harry is valiant, for the cold blood he did naturally inherit of his father... (Shakespeare, 4.2.104-106),” Falstaff seems to be attributing the declining morality of the kingdom to its internal divisions, which have stemmed from the war between father and son. 

     Henry IV, Part II is another great classic in the history of English literature. Shakespeare's story of a king facing the consequences of a successful revolution against a weakening realm is as relevant now as when it was written. Throughout history, people eventually become weary of every government or political party, and the established institutions themselves become challenged by a potential overthrow. On a second note, however, Henry IV Part II also reflects the importance of Chivalry’s decline in the late Medieval era. Over time, the successors of knights would become “gentlemen” who did not seek to work and toil for the protection of other people as their ancestors had done. The fact that knighthood was losing the dignity that it was once known for also demonstrates the turn of men from their noble duties to uphold God's law and protect their families. Falstaff's disposition of attaching a prize without a necessary battle beforehand reflects many modern men's sentiment that a woman's heart can be won without a struggle for her honor. Just as honor slips away from many in the second part of Henry IV, quite tragically, so also has it faded from most men in the modern world. 






 Works Cited:

No Fear Shakespeare: Henry IV Parts One and Two. (2005). 

Tuesday, July 18, 2023

New Details on My Plans

 



Next year, I will be beginning some sort of master's degree. A master's degree in history, historical theology, and Biblical languages are currently the programs that I'm most considering. From there, I will pursue either a Ph.D. in Medieval Historical Theology or in Medieval History. I may or may not do a master's thesis. I want to do my doctorate dissertation on something concerning the Crusades. 

Medieval History has for most of my life, always been my favorite subject. Though I have also considered a Ph.D. in New Testament in recent years, I have wanted to be a historian since I was fourteen years of age. At about fourteen, I gave my first lecture on history. My chosen topic was the American Civil War for a homeschool group that I was part of. Nevertheless, my study of New Testament topics and Biblical Studies, in general, has enriched my knowledge of Medieval Theology. 

With my love for Medieval History, I spent much of my High School years desiring to do a degree in either Church History or general history. In 2019, I made an unexpected change, though, I decided to major in English literature. I don't regret that decision. 

In many ways, majoring in English has been very informative to me. For example, I have learned more about grammar and writing from my degree. I have also got further acquainted with the great writers of the past. Indeed, I have also learned about publishing and editing---important tools to me in getting my books published. Studying the literature of the past has been a joyful experience. I see the English major as the most essential degree for anyone who wants to be a novelist. I'm proud of English literature degrees for increasing writers' creativity and analyzing skills. That said, history, has historically been my favorite subject. Had I not majored in English, I would feel more lost about where to proceed with my books in getting them published. English made me a better writer. History, however, is my chosen field to be a professor. In many ways, I consider English one of the best degrees on the market. By majoring in English and eventually doing graduate study in history, it allows me to get the best out of my two favorite disciplines of study. 

Then there is seminary. I have had theological interest primarily since the age of thirteen. As my mother read me a book about Early Christianity and how the Early Christians were led by a plurality of elders, I began to question other forms of church government that I had seen that had not been based on this practice (particularly the single pastor with deacons and committee groups as is common in many Baptist Churches). By seventeen, my study of Early Christianity had enlightened me to the realization that the Early Christians had a view of the Eucharist very different from most contemporary Baptist Churches. 

Unfortunately, it is far too common for people in many American churches to hold onto traditions that they were raised to believe and never question them. Many Presbyterians, Anglicans, Methodists, and Lutherans never examine the lack of historical evidence for baptism by sprinkling in the ancient church. Likewise, many Baptists assume what their pastors and theologians tell them about the Lord's Table as if these men were mini-popes. 

I learned a long time ago that it's much easier to take someone else' word for what is correct theology rather than doing one's own research in the Bible and church history. Doing the latter is simply much harder. 

Whether or not I end up a pastor or priest, I'm strongly convinced that a knowledge of Biblical languages and Biblical as well as Historical theology would benefit every believer. These are some reasons that I wish to pursue graduate studies in seminary as well. 

I'm not certain whether I will be pursuing a master's in history or a master of arts in seminary. I will likely do the latter as I have pastoral intentions. I hope to learn at least some Greek and Hebrew for theological purposes. As a matter of interest, Historical Theology probably intrigues me more than learning Biblical languages though I do see great value in both. 

In general, literature, history, and theology are my three main interests. I am quite likely that I will be pursuing a degree in each. Thankfully, Liberty allows those who get master's degrees in theology to still pursue a Ph.D. in history. 

I've had a lifelong love for history. When I was a young boy, I would love to look at the pictures in Usborne Books concerning castles and knighthood. Before I moved to Knoxville TN in 2005, one of my closest friends in Jacksonville NC had a strong interest in the Arthurian legends as I did. We frequently played the Wars of Camelot. When I moved to Knoxville, though, most of the children that I interacted with had less interest in Medieval literature than I did. For several years thereafter, some of my interest in Medieval Times was detained as a result until I began writing my own novels on the Crusades in 2010. 

Right now, I'm trying to get LU to add classes in Latin. Having taken two years of Latin in High School, I hope to be familiar enough with the Latin language to help my Medieval dissertation. I've wanted to be a formal researcher in Medieval Times for a long time. I'm coming closer now to that reality. 

Saturday, June 17, 2023

The Importance of Early Christianity Within Medieval Thought

 



Medieval scholars studied one of four fields at the university: theology, law, medicine, or the arts. The University of Paris was known to be the best concerning the instruction of theology. To many Medieval people, theology was the most respected discipline that a student could study in the university. 

It cannot be underestimated how important theology was to many people in the Middle Ages. Indeed, many commentaries on the Bible were written in Medieval Times. Read Thomas Aquinas, Pope Innocent III, or Bonaventure---whether or not you agree with their interpretations of Scripture, it would be unimaginable to believe anyone claiming them to be ignorant of the Bible. They defended Christian doctrines as they understood them. Aquinas appealed not merely to philosophy but to Scripture as well. In his commentary on Romans, Aquinas did an amazing job of breaking Paul's ideas concerning justification. To Aquinas, Paul did not teach justification by faith alone as Luther would later believe. Instead, the ''Dumb Ox'' believed that Paul was distinguishing the works of the law from the law of faith (Romans 3: 27). Aquinas also held that justification is progressive---Catholic Christians, he believed continue to become justified before God. 

When discussing theologians like Pope Innocent III or Thomas Aquinas, however, we must ask ourselves, what was at the core of their theology? Of course, they frequently quoted Ancient and Medieval fathers before them but the New Testament was essential to all that they believed (and the Old Testament as well). While Scripture in general, had aided much of the Medieval mind, the Gospel of Matthew played a significant influence on the thoughts of those who lived in the Middle Ages. In general, the medievals further developed many of the teachings found in the New Testament and Early Christianity---which brings me to my next point. 

It's impossible to understand the Middle Ages without understanding Medieval Christianity and it's impossible to understand Medieval Christianity without studying the New Testament and Early Christianity. For example, historians should understand that the doctrines of the medievals concerning the debates over the filioque largely originated from Jesus's relationship to the Holy Spirit in the Gospel of John (John 14: 16, John 14: 26). Likewise, medievalists must be acquainted with Athanasius of Alexandria and his thoughts on the incarnation of Christ (C. S. Lewis stated that the Incarnation of Christ (John 1) was central to Medieval thought) in order to understand the theology of those in the Middle Ages. During the fourth century, when many in Christendom were challenging the doctrines of the Trinity, Athanasius elaborated on the Divinity of Christ in his work, On the Incarnation. 

So what should medievalists study? The warfare, the siege weapons, the fashions, the daily lives of the people, etc. All of these are worthy fields for experts to engage much of their time. However, every medievalist should be familiar with both the Old and New Testaments as well as the history of Early Christianity in order for people to understand the teachings of the Latin Church, which had a profound influence on many in Christendom in the Post-Classical world. 


Friday, April 28, 2023

The Relevance of Medieval Studies

 



Recently, I have been most grateful to see Liberty University's openness to my many requests over the last several years that they add Medieval Studies. My work in this area has not gone unnoticed. When Liberty University adds Medieval Studies, it will be the first evangelical university in the nation to offer such a program. Currently, the colleges and universities that offer Medieval Studies are Mainline Protestant, Roman Catholic, and secular. It's important that Evangelical Christians, however, be familiar with the history of the church after Constantine and before Luther.I've always loved the study of the Middle Ages. When I began to learn about Medieval Studies several years ago, I was always excited about the idea of studying the Middle Ages but never felt that Liberty University would add such a program. Liberty, though, has expressed so much more openness to the study of church history before the Reformation than do many other Baptist schools. For Roman Catholics and Protestants alike, Medieval Studies is important for many reasons including knowledge of the great theological debates concerning the authority of the papacy that escalated in the sixteenth century. 

The Middle Ages were not the ''Dark Ages.'' Even when Petrarch used this term about the Middle Ages, he did not mean it in the sense of a theological derogatory manner as so many leftists and fundamentalists of today (ironically, this is one area where the two groups often agree; they both criticize Medieval Catholicism). Rather, those of the Italian Renaissance saw the Middle Ages as an era lacking the artistic creativity of the classical world that they sought to imitate. Certainly, Petrarch, a Roman Catholic, never felt that Christianity had been theologically ignorant or corrupt for a thousand years or longer as some on the left as well as right-wing fundamentalists have taught. No current historian believes ''The Dark Ages'' myth about the Middle Ages. This view is common with many in the public, unfortunately. Advancements in technology and alchemy did take place in the Medieval era. This was all the age of history that saw the opening of universities throughout Europe. Additionally, it was during the High and Late Middle Ages that many Europeans gained more fluency in Greek, began early naval exploration, etc. 
Medieval Studies is distinct from Medieval history. This is because the former studies all aspects of the Middle Ages including its history and its arts. To me, a certificate in Medieval Studies will be beneficial whether I get my master's in history, English literature, or in Biblical languages. Considering my interest to being a professor of a Medieval subject, this certificate will advance my credentials in whatever field that I teach (and also add to my resume). 
For anyone interested in knowing all aspects of the Medieval world, a degree or certificate in Medieval Studies allows them to further study other aspects of the Middle Ages outside of their own discipline. Those majoring in English may wish to know more about the castles of the Medieval world and those majoring in history may wish all the more to glance at the cultural impact of Chaucer and Dante's writings. 
Medieval Studies include the study of the Medieval church, the Crusades, intercultural relations between Muslims, Christians, and Jews, the artistic reveals of the High and Late Medieval eras (especially Chaucer and Dante's works), the flourishing of Chilvary, the role Manoralism, etc. I could go on and on about what Medieval Studies includes. No doubt, it is academically ideal for medievalists to study all aspects of the Medieval world. 

Wednesday, March 22, 2023

Where I'm Headed

  



 As of next year, I will be graduating with a degree in Christian literature from the English Department at Liberty University. In my degree, I have taken courses in topics such as theology and Medieval art, while from my Major, I have studied other areas such as Tolkien and Lewis as well as English literature in general, 

Previously, I was thinking about doing a master's in literature. I wished to obtain this degree to begin teaching English courses at the college level. For now, however, I've altered my path. 

For graduate studies, I wish to start with Liberty University's Master of Arts in Biblical languages from the John Rawlings School of Divinity. I wish to be involved in the planting of a liturgical low-church evangelical church in the Knoxville area. In general, I think God is calling me to this. The church will hold to the Thirty-Nine Articles of the Church of England. 

After my master's program, though, I may return to either English or history for a Ph.D. Longterm, I wish to be a university professor. At the moment, I probably lean toward history (though I'm open to either). My Ph.D. will probably have a specialization in the Medieval/Crusades era. 

Anyways, that's somewhat of an update on where I am currently. If I continue this new path that I now am leaning towards, I think that it will be beneficial to me for several reasons. 

1. With a bachelor's in English, I will have learned higher grammar, composition, and about literature in general. Indeed, all of these qualities have sharpened me as a novelist who wishes to get some of my books published in the near future. Studying English literature has taught me more about prose, poetry, and drama. I have read from some of the greatest writers in history such as Geoffrey Chaucer, William Shakespeare, and Jane Austen. Although many people read the writers from the past without majoring in English, English majors are taught to properly analyze and interpret literature. In many ways, I believe that English majors make the best writers. 

2. With a master's in Biblical languages, this would give me the opportunity to help my pastoral aspirations by understanding Biblical Hebrew and Koine Greek. Indeed, I also have a significant interest in the world of the first century, the literary aspects of the New Testament, and the study of early Christianity. The importance of Biblical languages cannot be overstated. For those especially interested in the New Testament, for example, it allows Biblical scholars to study the scriptures in their original languages, without replying upon another person's translation. Outside the Bible, knowledge of Hebrew and Greek can also benefit those studying historical documents from other writers of ancient times such as Josephus, Philo, and the works of early Christianity. 

3. If I should end up getting a Ph.D. in history with a specialization in Medieval Times, this would provide me the option to teach history for academia---a desire that I began at least as early as the age of fifteen. Over the years, I felt conflicted between the study of theology and history. I'm grateful, however, that Liberty allows those who study Biblical Studies/Biblical languages to be admitted into the doctorate in history. Furthermore, around 2019, I started to wonder if I should major in English rather than in history (part of my inclination towards English was due in part to the influence of J. R. R. Tolkien, C. S. Lewis, and Michael Shaara on my writings). Indeed, many novelists often major in either history or English, and for those who write historical fiction, there is debate about what major is better. Since Liberty does not currently offer a Ph.D. in English, it's hard to say what the future will hold. I'm definitely open to graduate studies in either English literature or history. Personally, I wish that history and English literature were seen more as one discipline (as they used to be) rather than two. I'm a huge fan of historical fiction, which is usually what I write, and this genre borders significantly on both. 

Interestingly enough, with a master's in Biblical languages and a master's thesis on early Christianity (my choice of topic), I will be a historian of the first century (if I do the thesis). Personally, I'm unsure yet whether or not I will do the thesis should I do this program. Likewise, if I should end up doing a Ph.D. in Medieval history then I will also be a historian of the Age of Chivalry. It would also mean that I'm I would be somewhat theologian (though arguably, more of a Biblical scholar as theology is more philosophical). As someone who has always found the study of early Christianity to be inspirational, knowing Hebrew and Greek would aid me in instructing others about its expansion throughout the Roman Empire. 

All of that said, I will begin a master's degree in divinity school as of next year. I appreciate all prayers for my benefit. Knowing the Biblical languages of the scriptures is not only important for theological debates over the meaning of baptism or church government, but defending the faith in a world that is increasingly hostile to Christianity. 

Saturday, February 11, 2023

Papal Supremacy and Medieval Celibacy

 



                                                                     Introduction: 



It is commonplace for Roman Catholic apologists to conflict with the historical record when the historical record doesn't benefit the teachings of Rome. This is the case, for example, in how many Catholic apologists present the Catholic Church as an unchanging church since ancient times. 

During the ninth and tenth centuries, the Medieval western church went through many changes and reforms. Belief in the sacrifice of the mass became widely accepted during this time, as I was learning from Anthony E. Gilles's The People of the Faith. This book, which is about the history of Christianity during the Middle Ages, also has other invaluable histories of other aspects of historical theology within it. 

One of the most striking aspects of Gilles's book that I have learned is the complicated history of clerical celibacy in the early Middle Ages. While the Byzantine Empire had long had married priests, the west followed a pattern by the early Middle Ages that was more restricting (though, as shall soon be shown, clerical celibacy did not receive automatic universal support). 

Clerical celibacy had been first proposed in fourth-century Spain. The idea never gained much acceptance in the east and struggled to gain universal approval even in the west. Even during the eleventh century, Pope Gregory VII, a major reforming pope, came into conflict with married priests throughout western Christendom. He went so far as to mandate clerical celibacy as to separate married men who were already priests from their wives and children. 

With clerical celibacy being such a controversial issue, it makes us ask why? Why did the issue matter so much? In the east, the issue had never been a major one to the church. How did it become a major issue for the western church? 

This post shall address two points concerning clerical celibacy. The first shall demonstrate the lack of Biblical support for the mandating of clerical celibacy. The second shall show how and why it developed to as widely accepted in the medieval west. 


                                             1. Scripture and Clerical Celibacy


Peter the Apostle had been married (Matthew 8: 14). At least several of the apostles were married (1 Corinthians (9: 5). While some have suggested that Peter was a widower before he became pope, I believe that this is a forced interpretation of scripture----something certainly never mentioned in the New Testament. Exegesis aside, however, even if Peter had been pope after his wife passed, it's quite clear that many of the apostles were prominent leaders in the New Testament Church (Acts 15) and were clearly not living celibate lives. 

Scripture is clear that there were church leaders who were married. Some, though see 1 Corinthians 7: 1-7 as evidence that Paul set a new example for the church. Because of this, many have suggested that Paul believed celibacy was now ideal for church clergy. A major problem with the Roman Catholic view of 1 Corinthians 7: 1-7, however, is that Paul never mandated any such thing. He respected both celibacy and marriage as beneficial to the church. 

In conclusion on this first point, scripture simply does not teach the Roman Catholic concept of a celibate priesthood. Since Catholics believed that their bishops are successors of the apostles, it seems unreasonable to believe that celibacy was required more for those who didn't walk with Christ than for those who had had a direct fellowship with Him. Paul exhorted celibacy and encouraged the church in that direction, but never called for any sort of mandate on those God called to ministry, in terms of them being withheld from marriage. 

So if scripture lacks support for clerical celibacy, how did it become so common in the west? What were the reasons for the Catholic Church in promoting it?


                                        2. Papal Supremacy and Medieval Celibacy


Several ancient bishops of Rome had been married. As mentioned earlier, clerical celibacy did not receive much support until centuries after Christ. Clerical celibacy did not receive universal recognition until at least the eleventh century (even then, it took another hundred years before an ecumenical western church council taught this as official teaching). 

The acceptance of clerical celibacy came at a time when much was drastically changing for western Christianity. The Carolingian Empire was exercising by this point an influence over church matters that had only once been shared by the Byzantines. The issue of the Filioque was also dividing Christians between the west and the east from each other. 

To make matters even more complicated, the papacy took on roles in the early Middle Ages that it had generally not done before. Popes came to see themselves gradually as having the right to institute kings into power. Gradually, there became a great rivalry between the Carolingian Emperors and those of the Byzantines. Likewise, the papacy and the Carolingians shared a different type of rivalry than between one king and another. Both the pope and the Carologian family saw themselves as the head of western Christianity. In the case of the papacy, much of this was attributed to its supposed authority from Emperor Constantine. This view had been elaborated within a work called The Donation of Constantine, which scholars later recognized as a forgery. Despite having been a forgery, however, the document showcased the view that Emperor Constantine gave his authority over Christendom to the bishop of Rome---a claim that the popes benefited from for centuries long after Constantine's reign. 

Much was changing in the ninth century. It was during this time (and slightly before) that the papacy became more central to the political affairs of Christendom. Despite no pope having been present at the first seven ecumenical councils of the Christian Church, the bishop of Rome was growing in influence upon the western church. These matters affected the church into the early eleventh century and beyond. 

With papal supremacy on the rise in the ninth century, it makes sense that this would change not just how people viewed the current pope, but also, how the doctrine of papal supremacy would affect other changes in the church. 

Emperor Henry II and Pope Benedict VIII were two key figures in the church's turn to clerical celibacy. These men lived during the early eleventh century. Much of my information on their relationship to this topic I've drawn from Anthony E. Gilles's book, The People of the Faith. 

Henry was quite authoritative over the church in his lands. He made sure to handpick all the bishops throughout his territory; saw their jurisdictions as his lands. Pope Benedict, a slick politician, managed to convince the emperor to give the pope complete independence from Italian rule. As a result, the pope ended up in a position of war against his fellow Italian states while attempting to assert his papal supremacy over the prominent Italian families. 

Both emperor and pope met at Pavia in 1022. They agreed to summon a council that would reinstate clerical celibacy throughout the Holy Roman Empire. Neither Henry nor Benedict sought clerical celibacy for any theological or moral reason---it was simply a way to grant the more power. In the case of Benedict, clerical celibacy benefited papal supremacy. 

The reason that clerical celibacy was important to Henry and Benedict must be understood because of the power that it would give each. During the eleventh century, one's heritage was important and sons often were the successors of their fathers. By promoting and mandating celibacy throughout the western church, it ensured that priests would have no successors to inherit church lands. For Benedict, this was important, as he wanted all church lands under his supremacy rather than in the hands of the local family. Likewise, the emperor benefited from church authorities who had no direct successors in their bloodline to challenge him for control of their claimed lands. 

While a universal reform for the church did not come about until after Benedict's death, the council of Pavia paved the way for the western church to accept clerical celibacy. Benedict had succeeded. The council mandated clerical celibacy for all those holding church offices. This accepted not only his power in the church but for all popes ever since. 

Although clerical celibacy became officially mandated in the church in the twelfth century, Pope Benedict had laid good reasons for its practice beforehand. Clerical celibacy was not about a scriptural or historical practice---it was simply to further papal supremacy as accepted teaching throughout the west. 


                                                              Conclusion:


It's truly ironic that many traditionalist Catholics see an end to clerical celibacy as a potential moral and theological failure for the church. To many of them, this is a liberal idea even though they are actually the ones embracing the liberal position. For most of Christian history, there were married priests in both the west and the east. 

As a final point, I do find it strange how so many people will hold onto ideas without questioning their origins. This is especially the case for many who believe in clerical celibacy being a rightful mandate from the church. Learning about how it evolved mostly from the desires of the pope and emperor for more power, shows me why more Christians should question its legitimacy. Certainly, I believe that the Protestant Reformation had good reason to bring the mandate of clerical celibacy into question. Likewise, the Church of England at the time of the English Reformation was not breaking from traditional western practice on this issue (as some medieval priests were married) but from papal supremacy itself. 


Further Sources: 

Anthony, E. Gilles. The People of the Faith. (1986). Messenger Press. 

Monday, February 6, 2023

A Review of The Bright Ages

 



Today, I would like to discuss a recent work on Medieval history that I read. It challenges the concept of the ''Dark Ages.'' The book was written by medievalists David M. Perry and Matthew Gabriele. 

I recently finished The Bright Ages. In general, I have mixed feelings about the book. For example, one of the areas where I disagree with the book is it makes a political point from cover to cover against white supremacy. Unfortunately, I feel that the authors see more people than Neo-Nazis as white supremacists. Frequently, far more so than its condemning of the far left, it condemns those that it considers being far right. The authors hardly fell short of showing their opposition to Trump's wall at the southern border, of making a constant point against the notion of western civilization, and constantly reminding the reader that not all people were white. 

I'm grateful for new research unveiling aspects of the past that we have not yet heard from our textbooks. However, I felt that the authors were politically motivated in their writing of a book that had more on its agenda than disproving ''Dark Ages'' myths. 

I have no problem with challenging previously held thoughts by some in the nineteenth century who wrongly believed that all Medieval Europeans were white. As The Bright Ages shows, there was a much greater complexity of race in Medieval history than many have properly understood. Whites and blacks both interacted throughout the Mediterranean, for instance. LIkewsie, I think that the book does a fine job of showing the complexity of religious groups in Medieval Times. Muslims, Christians, and Jews were not always enemies. Indeed, many of them interacted and worked together through trade and scholarship. The idea that the Crusades were the interaction between Christians and Muslims in Medieval Times is quite false. 

But while appreciating the authors demonstrating through historical evidence the over simplicity that many have perceived the Middle Ages as being, I disagree with their attempt to move away from other traditional views concerning the Middle Ages. For example, I see nothing that is white supremacist about America's roots in Europe or that most Europeans were historically white people. I also disagree with the book in that I think that the authors are being selective in their study of history. While discussing the complex relationship of Muslims and Christians in the Mediterranean, the authors seem to either forget or avoid the strong conservative orthodoxy of the Medieval Catholic Church. They avoid discussions of how Catholicism always saw unbelievers headed to the eternal fires. They also avoid writing about how much the far left of today prevents those with views akin to Medieval Catholicism as hatred and bigotry. 

There are some good aspects of The Bright Ages that I appreciated, however. For example, the authors did a fine job of showing that the traditional view of Rome falling in the fifth century is not the entire truth. Long after Rome was sacked in 410 AD, many of the medievals saw themselves as still within Roman history. To many of them, either Charlemagne or the Byzantines were the continuation of the old empire. Because of this, the medievals did not see a clear breach in time between the gradual decline of Rome in the fifth century and their own. 

Another aspect of The Bright Ages that I appreciate, is how much the book dispels common ''Dark Ages'' myths. The authors were well-versed in their knowledge of Medieval Times and were defined by far more than torture, plagues, and wars. This was the era in which Christian science was born; the time during which cathedrals were built, and the time that gave birth to great works of literature such as those by Dante and Petrarch. The book closes on Petrarch's understanding of the ''Dark Ages'' before him, making the argument that there never had been a dark age at all. 

The Bright Ages, however, does not discuss some views of the Middle Ages espoused by Fundamentalist Christians, who typically lack any formal education in either medieval history or medieval literature. For those wishing to hear common myths about the gospel supposedly being lost during Medieval Times, I recommend the following works (over The Bright Ages): 

Long Before Luther by Nathan Busenitz. 

The Discarded Image: An Introduction to Medieval and Renaissance Literature by C. S. Lewis

The Allegory of Love by C. S. Lewis

Positively Medieval: The Surirpsrins Dynamic Heroic Church of the Middle Ages by Jamie Blosser. 

While The Discarded Image and The Allegory of Love are more about Medieval literature than medieval theology, the latter directly deals with the myth that peasants were ignorant of the scriptures. The former, however, explains the literary knowledge in general that even many illiterate medieval people had. 

Blosser's book does an excellent job of showing the many great saints and heroes of the faith in the Middle Ages. In general, his book defends common misconceptions of the medieval church. A conservative Eastern Rite Catholic,  Blosser's book enlightens the reader about some of the great medieval minds such as Thomas Aquinas. 

Businitiz's book does not address the ''Dark Ages'' myths in general. However, as a graduate Ph.D. student from the Master's Seminary, the author did a very good job at showing that many Medieval Christians actually held to justification by faith alone. 

Finally, for those who wish to hear a more evangelical take on the Middle Ages, there is a great article from Houston Christian University (formerly, Houston Baptist) that defends Medieval Christianity as the authentic root of the Protestant Reformation. I am very grateful for this article. Specifically, it shows that the reformers were not so far off from medieval theology (even from the medievals who did not hold to Sola fide).  You can check it out here: 

https://hc.edu/news-and-events/2018/05/22/rethinking-the-reformation-reliance-upon-the-middle-ages/

In conclusion, I have mixed feelings about The Bright Ages. There are certainly better titles that I would recommend on medieval history.