Sunday, April 18, 2021

A Review of The Canterbury Tales: The Prologue to the Canon Yeoman's Tale





A canon and his yeoman* Chaucer find to be riding together. Chaucer describes how the canon met the pilgrims to Canterbury with a salutation: 

''God save,'' quod he, ''this joly companye!

Faste have I priked,'' quod he, ''for your sake.'' 

By-cause that I wolde yow atake,

To ryden in this mery companye.'' 

The host (Chaucer), welcomes both the canon and the yeoman into their company as he encourages the canon to tell a tale as the rest of their company have been doing. Chaucer finds the canon to wear simple garments even though he is so knowledgeable. Like his master, the yeoman cares little about his appearance. After the yeoman spends time conversing with the host, the canon catches rank with the pilgrims to Canterbury. The canon falsely accuses the yeoman of speaking ill about him as he always looks is suspicious of others. Chaucer explains that the reason for this suspicion of others is because the canon always speaks ill of others and assumes others talk ill of him. Already, Chaucer sides with the yeoman over the canon, and perhaps this explains more influence of John Wycliffe upon Chaucer as the latter reformer stood for the common man against some of the corruption of the clergy. 



The host reveals that the canon's words about the yeoman were simply not true. In response, the canon leaves as he feels sorrow and shame. Shortly thereafter, the yeoman tells a tale.

Chaucer was a mastermind of storytelling. He has left stories that has inspired writers even in the modern era such as J. R. R. Tolkien, C. S. Lewis, and J. K. Rowling. The Canterbury Tales is a timeless classic that has lasted the test of time. Here are words as fine as silk and poetry as beautiful as anything that had ever been written in the English language. 



*a yeoman was lesser than many nobilities though higher than serfs. 

Friday, April 2, 2021

A Review of The Canterbury Tales: The Prioress's Tale

 

1. The Tale




Geoffrey Chaucer's The Canterbury Tales are full of colorful figures and dark comical imagery. The fact that Chaucer was able to wield his pen and write of so many different types of stories puts him in rivalry only to Shakespeare. The Canterbury Tales teach theology, morals, and humour. It is unfortunate that Chaucer never got to finish these stories. With all the impact that The Canterbury Tales has had on English literature, imagine its influence if Chaucer had completed it. 




We come today to The Prioress's Tale. This Canterbury tale is more controversial as it portrays its Jewish characters as violent and oppressive towards Christians. Was Chaucer ant-Semitic? Scholars debate the outcome and meaning of the story. Some see the Prioress's Tale as reflecting Chaucer's bigotry towards the Jews. Others, however, insist that Chaucer was not anti-Semitic. Rather, scholars representing the latter view, see the story as satirizing common views about Jews that were popular in Chaucer's day. 

Chaucer's The Prioress's Tale starts off straight to the point. The tale avoids no time in portraying the Jews as being hateful to Christ and Christians in its opening words:  

Ther was in Asie, in a greet citee, 

Amonges Christen folk, a Jewerye,

Sustened by a lord of that contree

For foul usure and lucre of vilanye,

Hateful to Crist and to his companye;

And thurgh the strete men mighte ryde or wende,

For it was free, and open at either end. 


The story goes on to describe how at a local school Christian children were being taught. A young boy there always made frequent devotion to the virgin Mary. His mother, a widow, had raised him in this devotion. 

The boy, being so young, was not fluent in all the Latin liturgy at his school. The story depicts his lack of fluency in the Latin tongue: *

Noghte wiste he what this Latin was to seye, 

For he so yong and tendre was of age;

But on a day his felaw gan he preye

T'expounden him this song in language, 

Or tell him why this song was in usage;

This preyde he him to construe and declare

Ful ofte tyme upon his knowes bare. 


The young lad intends to learn Alma redemptoris (a Latin prayer) before Christmas. He is certain of his intention to honour the virgin Mary. 

The boy was taught by an older adolescent from the same school how to pray this prayer. Every day, the young lad piously invocating Mary, Mother of God. 

The story then describes how Satan rested in the hearts of Jews. Likewise, the devil urged them to persecute the boy as he passed by them praying Alma redemptoris. 

In reaction to the devil's command, the Jews hire a murderer that kidnaps the boy and slices his throat. Afterwards, the boy's body was thrown into a pit. 

Meanwhile, the poor widow had waited all night for her son to return. After waiting so long, she began looking for him. She cried out to the virgin Mary as she searched for her son in the Jewish ghettoes. The Jews falsely tell her that they have not seen her son. The Lord Jesus, however, reveals the location of her son's body. 

The mother came to find her son. Somehow, he was still alive and taken to the abbey. Later, it is found from the boy's lips that he should have died but that Christ preserved him anyways. 

In response to their wicked deeds, the magistrate has the Jews punished by torture, and then by execution. 

The boy reveals to his mother how the blessed virgin had been with him during his trial. He also reveals that when he sang to Mary, that she had placed a seed on his tongue. 

The monks bury the boy's body after weeping as they heard his story. This seems to indicate that it was the boy's ghost that had formerly appeared to his mother and those at the abbey. 

The story ends with describing the Jews as cursed and asking God for mercy while giving reverence to Mary. 


*Why does Chaucer mention this point? Is there a point in mentioning this besides the obvious of the boy's young age? Is Chaucer pointing towards the fact that many lay people in England were not as fluent in Latin as were the nobility and church hierarchy? Is Chaucer demonstrating a greater purpose hear? Does this reflect any Lollard tendency on his part? Does Chaucer support the scriptures being in the vernacular as did John Wycliffe? These are all questions that need to be addressed. 

2: Final Thoughts

This is an interesting story about the role of Jews and Christians during the Middle Ages. I can certainly see why this is a controversial story today. Nevertheless, whatever we think about it, it does reveal the tension between many Jews and Christians from many Medieval Times. For this reason alone, it is important for historical, religious, and literary discussions of the Middle Ages. 


Monday, March 22, 2021

A Review of The Canterbury Tales: The Prolugue to The Prioress's Tale

 



I think it has been about one year since I last discussed The Canterbury Tales in detail. I have wanted to return to this subject but one thing after another has just popped up. So, I have finally got back to finishing my reviews of each story from The Canterbury Tales by Geoffrey Chaucer. My hurt foot, college work, my readings of classical literature, theology, and The Norton Anthology of English Literature: The Middle Ages, have kept me distracted for a while. Now, however, I am ready to complete this series. 

In the beginning of the prologue to the tale, the Prioress praises God and speaks of how babes themselves adore Him. The Prioress holds both her Lord and the Blessed Virgin in high esteem: 

Wherfor in laude, as best can or may, 

Of thee, and of the whyte lily flour

Which that thee bar, and is a mayde alway, 

To tell a storie I wol do my labour;

Not that I may encresen hir honour;

For she hir-self is honour, and the rote

Of bountee, next hir sone, and soules bote.-


It is interesting that the Prioress refers to Mary, Mother of God, as the ''whyte lily flour.'' The fact that Mary was historically portrayed as a white redhead in much of Medieval art demonstrates the fact that not only were there more redheads at that time, but that many of the Biblical heroes were known to be white. Indeed, Esau is described as having ruddy skin in Genesis 22: 25. Likewise, Jacob tells his brother that he has a face like God (Genesis 33: 10). King David was described as having ruddy skin in scripture as well (1 Samuel 16: 12). Finally, Jews have historically been identified as white. Furthermore, the Jews were often painted as white redheads in Medieval art. The fact that many medievals did not like Jews shows that Medieval artist were not just painting what they perceived as the ideal look. It has been the more recent politically correct multi-cultural society of today, that wants to destroy classical western civilization. For many on the political left it is perfectly fine celebrating the history of minorities and the faith of Islam, but Christianity, and whites that are proud of their heritage, are true enemies of the intolerant leftist.  



After the lines quotes above, the Prioress reflects a strong Mariology that has historically been held by the church. She honours the Mother of God by talking about how Mary points us to Jesus Christ:

Lady! thy bountee, thy magnificence, 

Thy vertu, and thy grete humilitee

Ther may not tonge express in no science;

For som-tyme, lady, er men praye to thee,

Thou goos biforn of thy benignitee,

And getest us the light, thurgh thy preyere,

To gyden us un-to thy sone so dere. 


The Prioress reminds us in the prologue of the importance of the Blessed Virgin. We as Christians should learn from her speech to give her due honour as did the Ancient church father and Medieval saints. Now, with all that said, let me continue the discussion of The Prioress's Tale. 



Thursday, February 18, 2021

Books that I Have Read from or about Greco-Roman and other Ancient literature




Greek literature includes some great mythological and philosophical works of the Western Canon. The Iliad and The Odyssey are two of the main great works from Greek literature. As much though as I like Greek literature, I prefer the literature of the Romans and their descendants. Latin literature is possibly my favorite language-literature of classical literature. Of course, the influence of Latin language literature went well beyond that of the ancient and classical world. Some of the most important classics of the Medieval World were also written in Latin. This post, however, only lists literary works that I have read before the spread of Christianity in the fourth century. 

While most casual readers are familiar with Homer's The Iliad and The Odyssey, in many ways, Latin literature has had as greater influence upon Medieval literature (and therefore this medievalist) than did Greek literature.  The Aeneid by Virgil is one of many great works from the Romans.  Latin literature took much from the Greeks before it. Homer, was an inspiration to many of the Roman classical writers. 

We owe the Greeks and Romans much about the great philosophies and literature works that have transcended admired readers for many generations. Thousands of years after Homer, we are still enriched by some of the greatest stories of all time that originated with the Greeks and Romans.

Although English literature originated in the Middle Ages, {though some consider Beowulf to be an ancient work of literature}, there are plenty of books about The Greco-Roman World that is important for Literature major of all stripes to read and study. I may however, have forgotten the names of some books that I have read about the Greeks and Romans over the years. 
Books of Mythology: The Trojan War by Olivia Coolidge, Greek Myths by Olivia Coolidge 

Books on the history of the ancient and classical world: Augustus Caesar's World, The Osborne Time Traveler Book of Rome and Romans by Heather Amery and Patricia Vana, Marathon by David. J. Califf, Famous Men of Greece by John H. Haaren and A. B. Poland, Famous Men of Rome by John Henry Haaren. 

 Books of Literature: The Iliad by Homer, The Odyssey by Homer, Oedipus Rex by Sophocles, The Metamorphoses by Ovid, The Eclogues by Vigil, The Georgics by Virgil, Classics of Catholic Tradition: The Passion of SS. Perpetua of Felicity Together with the Sermons of Saint Augustine by W. H. Shewring, Treatise on the Passover by Origen of Alexandria, The Didache, First Clement, Second Clement, The Aeneid by Virgil. 




Orthodox Britain Part VII

 



For my previous thoughts: https://themedievalist.blogspot.com/2020/01/orthodox-britain-some-thoughts-on.html

https://themedievalist.blogspot.com/2020/01/orthodox-britain-some-thoughts-on_25.html

https://themedievalist.blogspot.com/2020/02/orthodox-britain-part-iii.html

https://themedievalist.blogspot.com/2020/04/orthodox-britain-part-iv.html

https://themedievalist.blogspot.com/2020/04/orthodox-britain-part-v.html

https://themedievalist.blogspot.com/2020/08/orthodox-britain-part-vi.html

I did formerly address the fact in the previous posts of this series of how the Anglo-Saxons did not support the reforming papacy of the eleventh century. I used this as support for the view that the Anglo-Saxons in 1066 were not Roman Catholic. Of course, it is also widely well known that many kings in the eleventh through fifteenth centuries opposed a high view of papal supremacy when it came to interfering with their power. Henry I of England and Anselm of Canterbury came into conflict on this issue for example.   





So, to continue my discussion of whether England was an Orthodox country rather than a Roman Catholic one, let me say that I believe it was a Roman Catholic kingdom in 1066. For that matter, essentially all of Western Europe was. The belief that stands contrary to this is the recently popular view that the Anglo-Saxon Church was an Orthodox Church. However, I see little historical evidence for either of these views. The wide acceptance of the Filioque among the Anglo-Saxons is a strong indication of them not being Eastern Orthodox, for example. Furthermore, I have never read from or about any Anglo-Saxon theologians who taught a type of Palamism that would later divide the Christian Church between east and west.

Some Anglicans saw evidence that the Celtic/Anglo-Saxon Church had been a pre-Anglican Church before the eleventh century. This view was espoused by Archbishop Matthew Park of Canterbury, for example. While I believe it is a stretch to claim that the Anglican Church goes back to the apostle Paul (as some belief), there is evidence, nonetheless, to back the idea of a pre-Anglican Church. However, for historical purposes, I believe that it is fairer to describe the church before the Norman Conquest as the Celtic/Anglo-Saxon Church rather than as the Anglican Church considering the great breach in time between the Norman Conquest and the English Reformation. After all, from the eleventh century through the sixteenth, the English Church was more or less Roman Catholic. While we may be able to describe the English Church before the Norman Conquest as Roman Catholic, I don't believe this would be the most historically accurate for several reasons. Among them would be the reasons that I have already discussed. Another evidence against the English Church being Roman Catholic before the English Reformation, however, is in the writings of Archbishop Parker. A scholar of Anglo-Saxon studies, he concluded that the Anglo-Saxons had never taught Transubstantiation. 




On the other hand, I do not think it is honest for some Roman Catholic apologists to claim that the Anglo-Saxons were Roman Catholic in the sense of the church's developing teachings on papal supremacy, which as I have shown previously, the Anglo-Saxons clearly rejected. The fact that the Anglo-Saxons had a long history of debt to the Church of Rome's Christianization of Britain is not sufficient evidence to prove that the English people somehow supported papal supremacy when the evidence shows otherwise. For certain, the Anglo-Saxons are indebted not only to Rome but also, to the Eastern Christians who brought their art to the British Isles. 





With all of this said, my view now is that the Anglo-Saxon Church was a Roman Catholic one, but this does not mean that the Anglo-Saxons supported papal supremacy any more than did many of the Norman kings in the following centuries that clearly opposed this theological position. Many of the Anglo-Saxons like their later Norman Conquerors, saw the king as the head of the church in their land.  The ongoing conflict of power between kings and popes would come to heads during the Protestant Reformation. Theologically, it may be argued that the Anglo-Saxon Church was more Anglican than Roman Catholic. Nevertheless, the British Church was more or less Roman Catholic in the simple sense that the Anglican articles of the Reformation hadn't been written yet! 






In summary, I would more or less affirm that the Anglo-Saxons were Roman Catholics that resisted a high view of papal supremacy that was becoming dominant in the eleventh century. While this may sound like an oxymoron, I believe that is because most today judge Roman Catholicism as a complete acceptance of the pope's dogmatic teachings. Such, however, was not the case for all Roman Catholic monarchs and their subjects in times past. The Saxons were Roman Catholic in the sense that they held communion to Rome but I would argue, that their theology was in many ways more Anglican than Papalism. 

Saturday, February 13, 2021

The Virgin Mary in the Protestant Tradition




                                                                       1. Introduction



Those that have followed my blog for a while know well that I have pointed out the historical fallacies of the modern Roman Catholic understanding of the papacy. They may also know well that I feel I have successfully proven that Papal Infallibility, and to a certain extant, Papal Supremacy, were later teachings in the history of the church. Today, I intend to blog on something from an opposite perspective of many modern  Evangelical Christians: I intend to show that many of them have gone too far in their rejection of Mariology. While I believe that many Roman Catholics are guilty of idolatry towards the Virgin Mary, others should not go to the opposite extreme of not honouring Mary at all. Unfortunately, many evangelicals, especially Independent Fundamentalist Baptist and those professing to be Reformed Protestant, are dead wrong on their complete rejection of Mariology. As will be discussed in another post, the Virgin Mary has been honoured in both scripture and history by Christians since the earliest of times. Far too often, has the Virgin Mary been cast aside in modern Evangelical Christian thought. 

Today, many Evangelicals will praise the Apostles Peter and Paul, but practically put their honour of Mary completely to the side. As soon as Mary is praised for her love of of her Lord, some are so fearful of giving honor to anyone but Christ (though actually they honor many other men besides our Lord) that they find any praise or honor of the Virgin Mary as simply being a Roman Catholic practice. 

The lack of reverence for Mary in low church Protestant and Evangelical circles is a remorseful thing. The time they do not spend in giving her the historical devotion that saints have shown her for two thousand years is replaced, if not superseded, by their love of their own theologians and pastors. The Virgin is extremely down played in such circles, they are quick to call her sinner, and much more slothful to honor her as did the Angel Gabriel: “Hail, thou that art highly favoured, the Lord is with thee: blessed art among women.” 

Before I proceed, the purpose of my post is not to defend many of the teachings of the Roman Catholic Church about the Virgin Mary. While some of the doctrines I find concerning, if not idolatrous, I also do think that many on the Evangelical side have fallen into error on the opposite extreme. While most Evangelicals probably play it safer than do many of the Roman Catholics, I think we should learn from church history that neither one is the historical one. This first post however, will only focus on what I perceive as the errors of many modern day Protestants and Evangelicals. While many Evangelicals will immediately resort to their false claim that the reformers only held to some Mariology as they were coming out of the church of Rome, they fail to understand that the reformers not only examined many of their beliefs (whether true or false) by scripture, and likewise, that many pentecostals can see evangelicals not going far enough from Roman Catholicism just as evangelicals like John Macarthur do when they claim erroneously that infant baptism needs to be reformed from. It is all who one compares oneself too when something is too ''Catholic.'' Many charismatic non-denominational Christians could see Southern Baptist as being too ''Catholic'' for anything structured in church worship. The point that I am showing here, is that the argument that the reformers were in error with anything evangelicals don't like because the reformers came out of the church of Rome, is a weak one.  


                                    2. The Reformers taught Devotion to the Virgin Mary



Let us look at what Protestants from the past said about the Virgin Mary. It is interesting how far most evangelicals have departed from the Protestant Reformation on this. 

"But the other conception, namely the infusion of the soul, it is piously and suitably believed, was without any sin, so that while the soul was being infused, she would at the same time be cleansed from original sin and adorned with the gifts of God to receive the holy soul thus infused. And thus, in the very moment in which she began to live, she was without all sin..."-Martin Luther

"The veneration of Mary is inscribed in the very depths of the human heart."-Martin Luther

"Elizabeth called Mary Mother of the Lord, because the unity of the person in the two natures of Christ was such that she could have said that the mortal man engendered in the womb of Mary was at the same time the eternal God."-John Calvin

"I firmly believe that Mary, according to the words of the gospel as a pure Virgin brought forth for us the Son of God and in childbirth and after childbirth forever remained a pure, intact Virgin."-Ulrich Zwingli 

"I esteem immensely the Mother of God, the ever chaste, immaculate Virgin Mary."-Ulrich Zwingli 

John Wesley too believed in the perpetual Virginity of Mary: The Blessed Virgin Mary, who, as well after as when she brought him forth, continued a pure and unspotted virgin. {"Letter to a Roman Catholic" / In This Rock, Nov. 1990, p.25}-John Wesley


I hope that all of this discussion here, will not cause knee jerk reactions from my evangelical friends. I encourage them to look more into these things before speaking about these things that they are usually ignorant of. Godspeed. 

Friday, January 15, 2021

How Modern Protestants Have Changed from their Sixteenth-Century Roots

 




                                                                            Introduction 



Today, it is quite common to find a division between various sects that profess to be protestants. Such is the case with the many modern Evangelical Christians, most of whom have never read any of the ancient creeds in their entire lives. Many Southern Baptists find themselves at odds with the very doctrines proposed during the Protestant Reformation although many of them still see themselves as Protestants. Confusion has grown among Roman Catholics about what Christians are truly Protestant, and gradually, many mainstream Christians have accepted any religious adherent to a western sect of Christianity that is not subject to the pope as being Protestant. The Pentecostals and Charismatics, along with the TV evangelists, are frequently described as ''Protestant'' by those that do not know any better. What many of these groups have in common though, is complete ignorance of the historic Reformed Protestant faith. By ''reformed'' I do not mean simply Calvinism, but also lower liturgical Protestants. 


                                                       1..Are Evangelicals Protestant?


The truth for the matter is that many Evangelicals today are not aware of  Protestant theology. In this present era, very few Southern Baptists, for example, have read the original confessions or creeds of the Protestant Churches from the fifteenth, sixteenth, and seventeenth centuries. While many Southern Baptists have embraced the doctrines of limited atonement or irresistible grace, the vast majority of them reject the sacraments as any means of grace to the elect (which was taught in several reformed confessions). Furthermore, Southern Baptists almost universally accept the practice of the altar call and decision theology, both of which are not only errors in doctrine, but alien to the ideas of the early reformers. 

Whether or not the reformers were right, we must ask ourselves if Evangelicals today would be considered Protestant by those of the sixteenth century. While Lutherans and some of the Calvinist churches still believe the papacy is Antichrist, many Evangelicals today do not. Likewise, most Evangelicals today are far less liturgical and confessional than were many of the early reformers. Though Lutherans agree with much of Luther's beliefs (though certainly not all of them), one might be able to argue that Lutherans have softened their view of total depravity from the view that Luther held in his writings. At the same time, many Calvinists today are more dogmatic about limited atonement than John Calvin was. In fact, some scholars including Norman Geisler and David Allen have interpreted Calvin to have taught unlimited atonement. 


                                                2. Have the Lutherans Departed from Luther? 

 


Sometimes, it is claimed by Calvinists that Luther taught limited atonement and later changed his view.  In his commentary on Romans, Luther said of some popular passages used for universal atonement that these verses only referred to the elect. As an example, he understood 2 Timothy 2: 10 as only applying to the elect. It has been argued that Luther, however, taught unlimited atonement in his later writings. Nevertheless, I have not done enough study on this subject to say if any of this is true. 



 



                                                      3. Are Anglo-Catholics truly Anglican?  


Today, many Anglicans would still claim to hold to the values of the English Reformation's The Thirty-Nine Articles. When closely examined though, the majority of Anglicans are actually quite far from Wycliffe and Cranmer. As an example, both Wycliffe and Cranmer taught that the papacy was Antichrist. Nowadays though, ecumenism has largely changed the face of Anglicanism. While we may debate whether the Ecumenical movement is a good or bad thing, I don't think it is historically accurate to claim that the Anglicans of the twentieth century have the same theology as those espoused by the Anglicans of the sixteenth century. 


                                                                         4. Final Thoughts: 


To be honest, I'm uncertain about who should be considered a ''Protestant'' and who shouldn't be. However, I think it is important that all recognize that most Evangelical Christians today are not in unison with all the ideas supported by the reformers. Of course, this could be either good or bad. The reformers were not infallible. Nevertheless, Evangelicals must see how their views have developed over time. Indeed, one needs to hardly study the reformers to see that several of them included a high reverence for the Virgin Mary that was much higher than many lower church Christians today would hold believe today. The Lutheran have Calvinist/Reformed churches have continued a greater opposition to the Roman Church than many Evangelicals have today. History has changed though, as have the circumstances surrounding theological debates. Finally, though the reformers felt that the Roman Church had erred, they never felt that the Roman Church had ceased to be a true church before the Reformation (unlike what Fundamentalists would later believe). 


 John Wycliffe compared the pope to Antichrist.
For as Christ putteth wisely his own life for his sheep, so Antichrist putteth proudly many lives for his foul life; as, if the fiend led the pope to kill many thousand men to hold his worldly state; he sued Antichrist's manners...
The Longham Anthology of British Literature (p. 518).